Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2002–2014

Packet One bet on WiMAX in Malaysia — industry chose LTE, company sold at a loss

Green Packet's WiMAX arm raised hundreds of millions from SK Telecom, Qualcomm and China Mobile, then lost to LTE and was sold to Telekom Malaysia.

Packet One Networks (P1) · Green Packet · Telekom Malaysia · SK Telecom · 2014-03

What happened

Packet One Networks (P1) was founded on 11 February 2002 as a subsidiary of Green Packet, a Malaysian technology company. It was established to deploy 4G WiMAX services in Malaysia, becoming one of four companies awarded 2.3 GHz spectrum licenses in March 2007. In August 2008, P1 became the first company to launch commercial WiMAX services in the country, positioning itself as a broadband alternative to the established mobile operators.

P1 attracted significant investment from global technology and telecom giants. SK Telecom acquired a 25% stake in June 2010 for an undisclosed sum. Intel, Alcatel-Lucent, Qualcomm, and China Mobile all became strategic partners or investors. ZTE was awarded a US$28 million contract in 2009 to expand the network. P1 appeared to have everything — spectrum, funding, and world-class partners.

The problem was that the world was moving to LTE, not WiMAX. As mobile operators globally adopted LTE as the 4G standard, WiMAX became a technological dead end. P1 could not achieve the scale or network quality to compete with established Malaysian operators like Maxis, Celcom, and Digi. Subscriber growth stalled and the losses mounted. Green Packet, which had poured resources into P1, was forced to sell.

In March 2014, Telekom Malaysia acquired a 57% controlling stake in P1 for RM350 million (approximately US$107 million at the time). TM also committed RM1 billion in additional investment over the following four years. The acquisition was effectively a bailout — P1 was rebranded as Webe Digital in 2016 and later absorbed into TM's mobile arm, Unifi Mobile. Green Packet, the company that had bet its future on WiMAX, effectively exited the telecom space.

Why it happened

  • P1 bet the company on WiMAX, a technology that the global industry never fully adopted — LTE won the 4G standard war, and WiMAX became a technological orphan.
  • Despite billions in ringgit invested and partnerships with SK Telecom, Qualcomm, and Intel, P1 had no path to scale against incumbents with superior networks and deeper pockets.
  • Green Packet's founder bet on first-mover advantage with WiMAX spectrum, but being first meant nothing when the technology itself was the wrong choice.
  • Strategic investors (SK Telecom, Qualcomm, China Mobile) provided funding and credibility but did not solve the fundamental problem: P1 was selling a technology nobody else wanted.
What it costRM350M distressed sale; billions lost; company absorbedcostly

The lesson

Betting on the wrong technology standard is a strategic error no amount of funding can fix. When the industry converges on a competing standard, first-mover advantage becomes a first-mover liability.

Aftermath

After TM's acquisition, P1 was rebranded as Webe Digital in April 2016. In January 2018, it was relaunched under TM's consumer brand Unifi Mobile. In March 2023, the entity was renamed TM Technology Services Sdn. Bhd. Green Packet, the original parent, pivoted away from telecom and focused on IoT and data services. The failure of WiMAX in Malaysia remains a textbook case of betting on a losing technology standard.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →