What happened
Calyon was the corporate and investment banking arm of Crédit Agricole, one of Europe's largest banks. Its New York proprietary trading desk specialized in credit derivatives.
In October 2007, Calyon announced a $347.5 million charge from unauthorized trading by its New York prop desk. A 26-year-old trader, Richard 'Chip' Bierbaum, had built large positions in credit market indices above his authorized limit in late August. The trades were executed on the bank's own balance sheet without the required approvals.
Risk managers only discovered the unauthorized position days later when they returned after the Labor Day weekend. Bierbaum was immediately fired. He publicly rejected the 'rogue trader' label, claiming his positions were reported daily and that superiors considered him a 'golden child.'
The loss sharply reduced Calyon's third-quarter profit. Trading limit alerts and security controls were immediately strengthened. The incident raised questions about whether Calyon's risk management systems met MiFID regulatory requirements, with ILOG publicly criticizing the delay in detection.
What it cost
Calyon's risk managers only caught the unauthorized $350M position days later, after Labor Day weekend, when the trader had already built it on the bank's balance sheet.
Why it happened
Bierbaum built a large credit derivatives position above his authorized limit on the bank's own balance sheet, taking proprietary bets without proper approval.
Calyon's risk management failed to detect the unauthorized position for days — the desk was discovered only when managers returned from the Labor Day weekend.
The bank's trading limit alerts and supervisory controls were inadequate for a proprietary desk operating with the bank's balance sheet.
The lesson
A 26-year-old trader betting $350M of the bank's money is not a star — he is a risk that someone should have been watching. Calyon's Labor Day weekend cost $350M.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
The sources
- Wikipedia — List of trading losses en.wikipedia.org
- New York Times DealBook — Calyon Trader Rejects Rogue Mantle archive.nytimes.com
- Risk.net — Rogue traders cost Calyon $358 million risk.net
- MarketWatch — Credit Agricole warns of rogue trade at Calyon marketwatch.com