The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Operational decision · 1984–2024
Shima's ¥170M women's clothing retail in Hokkaido collapsed after 40 years
A Hokkaido women's clothing retailer targeting middle-aged and older customers lost 40% of its revenue as COVID crushed physical retail in regional Japan.
Shima Co., Ltd. · 2024-02-19
What happened
Shima Co., Ltd. was a Hokkaido-based women's clothing retailer targeting middle-aged and older women, operating directly managed stores under the Tsurugaya and Nishitaga names in Fukagawa and Sapporo. Founded in 1984 and incorporated in February 1992 with ¥10 million in capital, the company served a loyal customer base in northern Japan.
The company peaked at approximately ¥250 million in annual revenue, but the COVID-19 pandemic devastated foot traffic to physical clothing stores. Unlike younger consumers who shifted to online shopping, Shima's middle-aged and older demographic was hesitant to buy clothing online, so they simply stopped purchasing. Revenue fell to approximately ¥150 million by the fiscal year ending January 2023, a 40% decline. The company recorded consecutive deficits, fell into debt overhang, and ran out of cash.
Shima filed for voluntary bankruptcy on February 19, 2024, with approximately ¥170 million in liabilities.
Why it happened
- Revenue fell from ¥250 million to ¥150 million, a 40% decline — a regional retailer serving an older demographic watched its customers stop coming to physical stores.
- COVID-19 crushed foot traffic, and Shima's middle-aged and older customers did not shift to online shopping — they simply stopped buying clothes.
- A 40% revenue decline is fatal for a small retailer with fixed rent and payroll costs — the company had no digital channel to replace lost in-store sales.
- Founded in 1984, the company had 40 years of local customer relationships, but loyalty could not compensate for a physical-only model in a post-COVID retail environment.
The lesson
A retailer serving older customers cannot assume they will shift online when physical stores close — they often stop buying altogether, and a 40% revenue gap has no digital bridge.
Aftermath
Shima Co., Ltd. filed for voluntary bankruptcy on February 19, 2024, with ¥170 million in liabilities. Founded in 1984 and incorporated February 1992 in Fukagawa, Hokkaido, the company operated women's clothing stores under the Tsurugaya and Nishitaga names targeting middle-aged and older women. Peak revenue of ¥250 million fell to ¥150 million in FY January 2023, a 40% decline. COVID-19 devastated physical store traffic and customers did not shift online. Attorney Katsunobu Oguma was named bankruptcy trustee.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Asics Trading ends four of its own shoe brands — everything becomes ASICS
A 43-year-old Japanese shoe brand gave up its stores and went back to being a contractor
Right-on shrank from 500+ jeans stores to 230 in a decade and was absorbed by World
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.