Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Sales & Retail · Strategic decision · 2020

Lord & Taylor was America's oldest department store — and it closed all 38 stores in 2020

Lord & Taylor, founded in 1826, was America's oldest department store. It closed all 38 stores in 2020 after a private equity buyout and the pandemic.

Lord & Taylor · 2020-08

What happened

Lord & Taylor, founded in 1826, was the oldest department store in the United States. For nearly 200 years, it was a fixture of American retail, operating stores across the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic.

The store's decline accelerated after a series of ownership changes. In 2019, Lord & Taylor was acquired by Le Tote, a clothing rental startup, in a deal that left the department store with significant liabilities. When the pandemic hit in 2020, the already-struggling chain could not survive the store closures.

In August 2020, Lord & Taylor announced the closure of all 38 remaining stores, ending a 194-year history. The case illustrated how a heritage brand can be destroyed by a combination of structural decline (department store format), financial engineering (private equity and startup acquisitions) and an external shock (pandemic). The brand's age was not a protection — it was a measure of how much had been lost.

Why it happened

  • Lord & Taylor's department store format was in structural decline.
  • A series of ownership changes, including a 2019 acquisition by Le Tote, left the company with liabilities.
  • The pandemic forced store closures that the already-struggling chain could not survive.
  • All 38 stores closed in 2020, ending a 194-year history.
What it cost194-year-old brand closed; 38 stores; thousands of jobscatastrophic

The lesson

A brand's age is not a moat — it's a measure of how much has been lost. Lord & Taylor was 194 years old, but its model was decades out of date. The age was the tragedy.

Aftermath

Lord & Taylor's brand was acquired and relaunched as an online marketplace. The physical stores were all closed. The case is cited alongside Barneys, Neiman Marcus and Debenhams as an example of the global department store collapse.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →