The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 1996–2003
GM built 1,100 electric cars — then recalled every one and crushed them in a junkyard
The EV1 worked. Lessees loved it. GM recalled every car, refused to sell, and crushed most in an Arizona junkyard. Tesla proved the market twelve years later.
General Motors
HearsayWidely repeated, and we cannot show you a document for it. Read it for the lesson, not as fact.
What it means today
Every company that has killed a product to protect its existing revenue model — the newspaper that buried the digital edition, the taxi company that fought the app — is GM crushing the EV1. The product was not the threat. The product was the warning.
What happened
The General Motors EV1, launched in 1996, was the first purpose-built electric car from a major manufacturer. It was available only by lease, only in California and Arizona, and only to applicants who passed GM's screening. About 1,100 were built. The lessees — mostly environmentalists and tech workers — loved the car: instant torque, no oil changes, home charging, near-silent operation.
In 2003, GM announced it would not renew the leases. Lessees offered to buy the cars at any price; GM refused. The cars were recalled. Most were crushed and compacted in an Arizona junkyard. A few were donated to museums and universities, with their drivetrains disabled. The factory floor story, as the technicians told it, was that they were ordered to destroy cars that worked.
GM's official reasons: the EV1 was not profitable, parts were scarce, and the company needed to focus on trucks and SUVs. The unofficial reason, as the trade tells it: the EV1 threatened GM's core business (internal combustion, dealer service revenue, oil-company partnerships) and the California mandate that had created it was being weakened by legal challenges. GM killed the car to protect the business model the car was designed to replace.
Why it happened
- The EV1 was a compliance car, built for California's zero-emission mandate. When the mandate was weakened by legal challenges from the auto industry, the regulatory reason for the car disappeared
- The lease-only model meant GM owned every car and could recall them. If the EV1 had been sold, the owners would have fought. The lease structure gave GM the power to destroy the product
- The EV1 threatened GM's core business: every mile on electricity needed no oil change, no transmission service, no dealership visit. The car threatened the revenue model, not just the product
The lesson
A company that builds a product to comply with a regulation, not to serve a market, will kill it when the regulation weakens. The EV1 was a compliance cost. Compliance costs are cut first.
Aftermath
The documentary 'Who Killed the Electric Car?' (2006) told the story from the perspective of the lessees and the factory workers. Tesla Motors was founded in 2003, the year the EV1 was killed. The Tesla Roadster (2008) and Model S (2012) proved the market GM said did not exist. GM re-entered the EV market with the Volt (2010) and the Bolt (2016).
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
GM built a car company that worked — then starved it for twenty years and killed it
GM's worst plant became its best under Toyota — then GM let it die
Genesis G80: a loose ground bolt that stalls the engine at speed
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.