From 12 May to 9 November 2025, Geo Store ran repeated 'limited-time' campaigns raising buyback prices for smartphones and tablets: 10% up, then 10% plus 15% on Tuesdays, then 20% on Apple products, then 20% across four device types — six campaigns chained together with no gap between them.
The Consumer Affairs Agency found the 'limited-time' framing misled consumers into believing the higher buyback price would disappear if they waited — when in fact identical or similar terms ran continuously for about six months. That was an advantageous misrepresentation (有利誤認) under Article 5(2) of the Act against Unjustifiable Premiums and Misleading Representations.
On 11 June 2026 the CAA issued an administrative order under Article 7(1): Geo must stop the representations and take measures to prevent recurrence. It was the first such order in the buyback industry since the CAA's 18 April 2024 guideline revision made buyback services subject to the Act's coverage.
Geo Holdings said it would take the order seriously, strengthen compliance education on the Act for executives and employees, and improve its system for reviewing and approving advertising. It said the impact on earnings was under review.
The CAA's first buyback order ruled the urgency was a fiction: identical terms ran continuously, making the deadline the misrepresentation.
A deadline that never arrives is not a deadline: six campaigns ran back-to-back, so waiting cost the customer nothing — and the urgency was the lie
The 'limited-time' framing did the selling: without the fictional deadline, a 10-20% bump that is always on is just the price
The order was a first for the whole industry — the 2024 guideline change that brought buyback services under the Act got its first enforcement
A 'limited-time' offer needs an end that is real. When the same 10-20% bump runs for six straight months, the urgency is the misrepresentation — and the regulator now has a rule to call it by.
The order requires Geo Store to cease the representations, publish a notice to consumers and put prevention measures in place. Geo Holdings pledged compliance education for executives and staff and a stronger advertising review and approval system. Industry commentary (isotop, ITmedia) read the case as the first enforcement of the April 2024 guideline revision, and a signal that buyback promotions run on evergreen urgency would now be measured against the same rule as any other sale.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE