Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Software & IT · Financial decision · 2018–2025

eFishery was Indonesia's first unicorn — $600 million of its revenue was fake

The smart fish feeder startup raised $200M at a $1.4B valuation. Then a whistleblower showed the board two sets of books: one real, one for investors.

eFishery · 2025-01-21

What happened

eFishery was founded in 2013 by Gibran Huzaifah, a Bandung Institute of Technology graduate who had experienced the inefficiency of aquaculture first-hand. The company built an IoT smart fish feeder that dispensed feed automatically, solving a real problem: feed costs represent 70–90% of a fish farmer's expenses. The product worked, farmers adopted it, and investors poured in. By 2023, eFishery had raised a $200 million Series D round from SoftBank Vision Fund, Temasek, and Northstar, reaching a $1.4 billion valuation — the world's first aquaculture unicorn.

The company was running two sets of books. The external version showed rapid growth: $752 million in revenue for the nine months to September 2024, with a $16 million profit. The internal version told a different story: actual revenue was about $157 million, and the company was losing $35 million. Investigators later estimated that roughly 75% of reported sales were fabricated — nearly $600 million in inflated revenue, maintained since roughly 2018.

The fraud was exposed in December 2024 when an insider alerted the board to accounting irregularities. The board suspended Gibran and deputy Andri Yadi, installed an interim CEO, and brought in FTI Consulting for a forensic review. In January 2025, a leaked draft of FTI's report made headlines. By February, shareholders had handed control to FTI. The company's claimed 400,000 smart feeder units turned out to be about 24,000 functioning devices.

Gibran Huzaifah was sentenced to nine years in prison for embezzlement and money laundering, reduced to six years on appeal in July 2026. Andri Yadi received seven years, reduced to four. Investors lost heavily: Malaysia's KWAP pension fund alone sought to recover RM163.4 million. The case became a landmark for Indonesia's startup ecosystem, illustrating how a genuinely useful product could be undermined by fabricated financials.

Why it happened

  • eFishery maintained two sets of books — one for investors and auditors, one reflecting reality — so the fraud was invisible to anyone who relied on the external reports.
  • Routine audits by PwC and Grant Thornton failed to detect the discrepancy, so the fraud continued for years without external challenge.
  • The founder's compelling story — a hungry student who built something real — made investors reluctant to question the numbers, a pattern the ecosystem called 'rewarding familiarity over proof.'
  • The company's real business was viable and growing, creating a perverse incentive to inflate rather than wait: the fraud was, in one investor's words, 'not just criminal but pointless.'
What it cost$600M in fabricated revenue, $300M in investor lossescatastrophic

The lesson

A real product and a real market do not protect against fabricated financials. The most sophisticated money in the world can sign off on fiction if the person telling the story is compelling enough.

Aftermath

eFishery's board handed control to FTI Consulting, which managed the company through forensic review. Gibran Huzaifah was sentenced to 9 years (reduced to 6 on appeal), deputy Andri Yadi to 7 years (reduced to 4). The case had a chilling effect on Southeast Asian startup fundraising, adding months of due diligence overhead to every growth-stage round in Indonesia. KWAP, a Malaysian pension fund, pursued recovery of RM163.4 million. The fraud joined TaniFund and Investree as cautionary tales of Indonesian startup governance failures.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →