Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Marketing decision · 2012

Bic made a pink pen 'for her' — and became a punchline

Bic repackaged its standard Cristal pen in pink and purple, called it 'Bic for Her.' The internet did the rest.

Bic (Société Bic) · 2012

What happened

In 2012, Bic launched the 'Bic Cristal for Her' — a ballpoint pen identical to its classic Cristal but offered in pink and purple pastel colours, packaged in a box labelled 'For Her.' The product was positioned as a pen designed specifically for women, with marketing copy suggesting that women needed a pen that fit a woman's hand. The pen itself was mechanically identical to the standard Cristal, which cost a fraction of the price.

The reaction was immediate and merciless. Ellen DeGeneres mocked it on her show: 'Can you believe this? We've been using man pens all these years.' Comedian Bridget Christie built an entire Edinburgh Festival show around it, titled 'A Bic For Her.' Amazon reviews became a genre of satire, with customers posting elaborate parodies about how the pen finally let them write recipes and shopping lists properly. The product became a global symbol of tone-deaf gendered marketing.

Bic never announced an official discontinuation, but the product faded from shelves within a few years. In 2017, it was inducted into the Museum of Failure in Sweden, cementing its status as one of the most ridiculed product launches of the decade. The episode did not materially damage Bic's bottom line, but it became a permanent footnote to the brand's history — and a textbook example of why 'shrink it and pink it' is not a product strategy.

Why it happened

  • The pen was identical to the standard Cristal — the only change was pink and purple plastic, which made the 'designed for women' claim transparently hollow
  • The marketing implied women could not use a regular pen, which was insulting rather than inclusive — the product solved a problem that did not exist
  • The internet turned the product into a global joke within days, drowning any possible positive reception in mockery
What it costReputational damage; product pulled within yearsembarrassing

The lesson

Shrink it and pink it is not a product strategy. If the only difference is the colour, the customer knows you are not solving a problem — you are selling a stereotype.

Aftermath

Bic for Her became a permanent exhibit in the Museum of Failure (2017) and a case study in gendered marketing failures. The backlash did not hurt Bic's core business, but it forced the company to confront how its brand was perceived. In 2020, Bic experimented with a 'Bic For Them' campaign aimed at inclusivity, a direct response to the 2012 debacle. The episode is taught in marketing courses as a limit case of segmentation: identifying a demographic is not the same as understanding one.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →