Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2025–2026

BHV Marais tried Shein to stay relevant — it destroyed the store's soul and forced a sale

BHV Marais brought Shein into a 170-year-old Paris department store to attract youth — it backfired so badly the owner had to sell to his own management team.

BHV Marais · SGM (Société des Grands Magasins) · Brookfield Asset Management · Shein · 2026-06-16

What happened

In 2020, young entrepreneur Frédéric Merlin acquired BHV Marais from the Galeries Lafayette Group with an ambitious plan to reinvent the 170-year-old Parisian institution. His most controversial bet: bringing Chinese ultra-fast fashion giant Shein into the store as a concession, hoping to attract younger shoppers and shake up the department store's staid image.

The Shein experiment backfired catastrophically. Longtime BHV customers — who came for homewares, DIY tools, and curated French brands — were alienated by the presence of a brand synonymous with disposable fashion and environmental criticism. 'We sowed discord in the store,' Merlin later admitted to Les Echos. The controversy damaged BHV's identity without generating enough traffic to compensate. Staff were demoralised, and the store's carefully curated brand mix was compromised.

By June 2026, Merlin's SGM had run out of money and options. The company was sold to its own management in a leveraged buyout led by general manager Carl-Stéphane Contentin. Brookfield, the Canadian asset manager that owned the building, effectively controlled the outcome — one of its conditions was that Shein must leave. Merlin acknowledged that he had 'lacked the funds to execute the strategy' and that the Shein experiment was a failed bet that had accelerated the loss of the business.

Why it happened

  • Putting Shein into a heritage Parisian department store was a category error — ultra-fast fashion's values directly contradicted BHV's identity, alienating core customers without attracting new ones.
  • Merlin lacked the capital to execute his vision — the Shein concession was a desperate attempt for quick revenue, not a coherent strategy, and it consumed resources needed for genuine repositioning.
  • The MBO and Brookfield's conditions showed the landlord had more control than the owner — Merlin borrowed heavily to acquire BHV and had no buffer when the Shein bet failed.
What it costBHV sold to management; founder lost control; Shein failedcostly

The lesson

BHV Marais brought Shein into a 170-year-old Paris store — it lost its soul, its customers, and its owner. A desperate short-term fix can destroy the identity that made the business worth saving.

Aftermath

Carl-Stéphane Contentin took over BHV operations through the MBO. Brookfield required Shein's removal as a condition of the transaction. BHV returned to its core homewares and DIY positioning, cutting the fashion concessions that diluted its identity. Merlin's SGM exited retail entirely. The case was widely covered in French business media as a parable of what happens when a heritage brand tries to buy relevance from its antithesis.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →