The encyclopedia · Marketing & Brand · Product decision · 2021–2025
Youthforia went viral for the wrong shade — one TikTok killed the brand
Youthforia promised inclusive beauty — then a viral TikTok called its darkest foundation shade 'tar in a bottle' and the brand shut down 4 months later.
Youthforia · 2025-08-04
What happened
Youthforia launched in 2021 as a clean, colorful beauty brand built around founder Fiona Co Chan's social media presence. The brand grew quickly, appearing on Shark Tank in 2023 where Mark Cuban invested $400,000. By 2024, Youthforia was sold at Ulta Beauty and Amazon, and had built a loyal following of young consumers drawn to its playful aesthetic.
The turning point came in 2024 when beauty influencer Golloria George posted a TikTok review of Youthforia's 'Date Night Skin Tint Serum Foundation.' George criticized the darkest shade (Shade 600) as 'tar in a bottle' and 'literally jet black.' The video went viral, amassing over 47 million views. The backlash was immediate: consumers accused the brand of performative inclusivity, retailers began dropping the line, and the brand's reputation collapsed.
Youthforia attempted damage control but never recovered. On August 4, 2025, founder Fiona Co Chan announced via Instagram Story that the brand was closing after just four years. A closing-out sale with 50% off everything was the brand's final act.
Why it happened
- Youthforia marketed itself as an inclusive brand but failed to formulate genuinely inclusive shades — a gap that one viral TikTok exposed permanently.
- The brand had no crisis management plan for a product-quality controversy, so the backlash spiraled from a single review to a brand-ending scandal.
- As a single-founder DTC brand with no corporate parent, Youthforia had no financial buffer to weather the retailer exodus and reputational damage.
The lesson
A single viral video can destroy a DTC beauty brand when the accusation — performative inclusivity — strikes at the heart of the brand's identity and no parent company stands behind it.
Aftermath
Youthforia's closure was announced via Instagram on August 4, 2025. The brand liquidated remaining inventory at 50% off. The case became a cautionary tale about the fragility of influencer-built DTC brands and the existential risk of social media backlash for companies with no institutional backing.
Sources
- Youthforia Is Shutting Down After Four Years — Marie Claire
- Youthforia, the TikTok-viral Beauty Brand, to Close — WWD
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
L'Oréal's Urban Decay hired an OnlyFans creator — and triggered a backlash
Tarte's Shape Tape Foundation launched in 15 shades — after Fenty reset the bar to 40
Vans collabs with a brand named Fugazi, fans think it's the band that never sold merch
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.