Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1979

Xerox PARC invented the GUI and mouse, then let Apple and Microsoft build empires on them

Xerox's Palo Alto lab invented the GUI, the mouse and the modern PC. Steve Jobs visited in 1979; Apple and Microsoft, not Xerox, built empires on the ideas.

Xerox · Apple · Microsoft · 1979-12

What happened

Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), founded in 1970, was one of the most extraordinary research labs in computing history. Working with unusual freedom 3,000 miles from Xerox headquarters, its scientists invented or pioneered a stunning list of technologies: the laser printer, Ethernet, object-oriented programming, and — most consequentially — the modern personal computer with a graphical user interface (GUI), windows and icons, operated with a mouse, on machines like the Xerox Alto.

Xerox, though, was a copier company, and its management struggled to see the commercial potential of what PARC had built. The famous turning point came in 1979, when Steve Jobs and a team from Apple visited PARC and were shown the Alto and its graphical interface, in a deal that included the right to buy Apple stock before its IPO. Jobs was electrified by what he saw; Apple went on to build the Lisa and then the Macintosh around the GUI-and-mouse paradigm.

Microsoft, in turn, brought the graphical interface to the mass market with Windows. The two companies Apple and Microsoft built trillion-dollar empires on ideas that PARC had pioneered, while Xerox never turned its own inventions into a comparable business. 'Xerox had it all,' the saying goes, 'and gave it away.' PARC's story is less about a single bad decision than about a company that could invent the future but couldn't imagine itself selling it.

Why it happened

  • Xerox's core business was copiers, so its management undervalued and under-invested in the personal-computer technologies PARC invented.
  • The 3,000-mile distance between PARC and headquarters gave researchers freedom but made it hard to persuade management to commercialize their work.
  • Letting Apple (and others) see PARC's work, including the GUI, handed competitors the ideas and the inspiration to build products Xerox didn't.
  • Xerox lacked the product, marketing and distribution muscle — and the will — to bring a personal computer to market itself.
What it costthe personal-computer revolution it inventedcostly

The lesson

Inventing the future is worthless if you can't ship it. Xerox created the GUI, the mouse and the modern PC, but its managers saw a copier company and let others commercialize the ideas.

Aftermath

Xerox PARC's innovations went on to underpin much of modern computing, but the commercial rewards flowed overwhelmingly to Apple and Microsoft, not Xerox. The lab's story is taught as the canonical case of brilliant invention divorced from commercialization — a reminder that research breakthroughs only create value for the company that makes them when that company is also willing and able to turn them into products. The phrase 'invented at Xerox, sold by everyone else' captures the lesson: owning the future in a lab is not the same as owning it in the market.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →