Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2017

France's ad regulator made Saint Laurent take down 'degrading' posters across Paris

Saint Laurent's spring 2017 campaign showed women in suggestive poses. After more than a hundred complaints, France's ad regulator ordered the posters down.

Saint Laurent · Kering · 2017-03

What happened

In early March 2017, Saint Laurent put up around two hundred posters across Paris for its spring campaign. Two images drew immediate criticism: one showed a woman in a fur coat and fishnet tights reclining with her legs open, her face barely visible; another showed a model in a leotard, stilettos and roller skates bending over a stool. Critics, including France's then families minister Laurence Rossignol, said the ads portrayed women in humiliating positions, and that one model looked almost anorexic.

France's advertising self-regulator, the ARPP, received more than a hundred complaints. Its head, Stéphane Martin, said such cases were extremely rare. On the Monday the ARPP wrote to Saint Laurent asking it to stop using the images and to withdraw or change them; by Wednesday night the posters had come down across the capital. The brand itself declined to comment.

The episode landed in the middle of a wider French debate about how fashion portrays women, and about ultra-thin models on runways and in ads. For Saint Laurent, the cost was not a fine but a public order to take its own campaign off the streets of Paris — a regulator doing in a week what critics had been demanding, and a reminder that a provocative image is judged by the room it enters, not the one it was made in.

Why it happened

  • The campaign treated shock as a creative value without weighing how degrading poses would read on a public street, as opposed to in a magazine spread.
  • France had a regulator with both the will and a fast process, so a campaign that might have run elsewhere was ordered down within days.
  • The brand's silence — declining to comment — left the regulator's 'degrading' framing as the only public account of the work.
What it cost~200 Paris posters ordered down; regulator rulingembarrassing

The lesson

Provocation is judged by the street, not the studio. What reads as edgy in a lookbook can read as degrading at bus-stop scale — and a fast regulator can end it before the brand speaks.

Aftermath

The ARPP's head stressed that formal orders like this were extremely rare, which was part of why the case drew attention. It came as France tightened rules on ultra-thin models and as Paris moved against sexist advertising in public space. Saint Laurent said nothing publicly and the campaign simply disappeared from the streets; the regulator's 'degrading' verdict, not the brand's intent, became the record of what the work meant.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →