Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2017

Pie Face raised $35M, reached 80 stores, and collapsed twice in three years

Australia's smiley-faced pie chain grew to 80 stores on $35M of funding, collapsed twice in three years, and ended as 30 stores sold to a petrol company

Pie Face · 2017

What happened

Pie Face was an Australian pie shop chain founded in Sydney in 2003 by Wayne Homschek. Its pastries topped with smiling faces became a national novelty, and with about $35 million in funding the chain grew to roughly 80 stores.

The expansion outran the economics. The chain first went into administration in November 2014. By January 2017 it was in receivership with about 30 franchised stores, $4 million in secured debt and nearly $5 million unsecured — more than $1 million of it owed to its own employees. The receiver said the business was close to profitability and drew seven or eight bidders.

On April 13, 2017, petrol retailer United Petroleum bought the brand, keeping about 80 staff, while tens of millions of dollars remained owed to lender Macquarie. The smiley pies survived as a side business of a fuel company — the chain's independent life was over.

Why it happened

  • Expansion came before the unit economics: the chain sprinted from one shop to 80, and the $35M of funding paid for growth the stores never earned back.
  • A franchise-heavy model multiplied exposure: when the parent wobbled, the brand's debts — $9M and rising — dragged every store's future down with it.
  • The lender ran out of patience: with tens of millions owed to Macquarie and no turnaround credible enough, receivership was the end of the road.
What it costTwo collapses; sold; ~$9M debt, $1M+ owed staffcostly

The lesson

A fun brand can outrun its balance sheet: at 80 stores the pie chain still could not pay for itself, and the smile on the logo never showed up on the profit and loss.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →