Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2026

PhysicsWallah auto-added a ₹10 donation at checkout — CCPA called it basket sneaking

A pre-selected 'Donate for PW Foundation' box added ₹10 to checkouts, backed by emotional prompts. CCPA fined the edtech firm ₹5 lakh for dark patterns.

PhysicsWallah Limited · 2026-06-01

What happened

PhysicsWallah — the Indian edtech firm known as PW — sells courses and test prep online. At checkout, its platform added a pre-selected 'Donate for PW Foundation' option that put ₹10 towards a charity donation without any explicit consent from the buyer. The prompt stayed live until 24 December 2025, even after the CCPA had taken notice of it.

Declining was discouraged with emotional prompts about children's education, healthcare and marriages, which the CCPA classified as confirm shaming, while the automatic donation itself was basket sneaking. A third pattern was forced action: courses advertised as 'free' demanded the user's mobile number and email address even though the content was identical without handing over data.

On 1 June 2026 the CCPA imposed a ₹5 lakh penalty for violating the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules 2020 and the Dark Patterns Guidelines 2023. It directed PhysicsWallah to ensure no dark patterns are deployed on any digital interface and to file a compliance report within 15 days. Consent, the order said, requires clear affirmative action — pre-selection is not consent.

Why it happened

  • A pre-selected box is not consent: the ₹10 donation became opt-out instead of opt-in, and charity framing made declining feel shameful.
  • Emotional prompts about children's education and marriages at checkout are confirm shaming — pressure on the refusal, not information about the choice.
  • 'Free' courses were not free: mandatory mobile and email collection turned course access into a data transaction users were never told about.
What it cost₹5 lakh fine; compliance report orderedembarrassing

The lesson

Pre-selection plus charity guilt is not consent: CCPA fined PhysicsWallah ₹5 lakh for basket sneaking and confirm shaming. Consent must be affirmative, and free must be free.

Aftermath

PhysicsWallah was directed to file a compliance report within 15 days and to keep dark patterns off every digital interface. The order came in the CCPA's June 2026 enforcement wave under the 2023 Dark Patterns Guidelines, alongside a ₹1 lakh penalty for McAfee's renewal prompts.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →