The encyclopedia · Trading & Investing · Financial decision · 2018–2020
Dutch pension fund PFZW lost €4B on oil futures — then called it worth it
The Netherlands' second-largest pension fund lost nearly €4B accelerating its exit from oil investments at the worst possible time.
Stichting Pensioenfonds Zorg en Welzijn (PFZW) · 2020-11-23
What happened
PFZW (Stichting Pensioenfonds Zorg en Welzijn) is the Dutch pension fund for the healthcare and welfare sector, the second-largest pension fund in the Netherlands with approximately €238 billion in assets.
In 2018, PFZW decided to gradually reduce its commodity investments, including oil, to zero. The fund had invested in commodities for diversification and risk spreading, and the strategy had delivered average annual returns of over 8% in previous years.
When COVID-19 struck in 2020, the economic downturn caused oil prices to crash — West Texas Intermediate crude briefly traded below zero for the first time in history. PFZW accelerated its divestment from commodities, selling at the market bottom. The accelerated reduction resulted in a loss of nearly €4 billion.
PFZW stated that the loss was due to the accelerated sale happening at a low point, but noted that the proceeds were used to buy other investments at low prices, which later recovered. The fund described the loss as an acceptable cost of exiting fossil fuel investments.
Why it happened
- PFZW accelerated its commodity divestment during the COVID-19 crash, selling oil holdings at the worst possible moment — when prices had collapsed to historic lows and briefly went negative.
- The fund prioritized its ESG commitment to exit fossil fuels over portfolio management timing, executing the sell-off during a market panic rather than waiting for prices to stabilize.
- The loss was not from a trading strategy per se, but from the timing of a politically motivated divestment — the fund chose to sell into a crash rather than delay its exit from oil.
The lesson
A principled exit from a sector is a plan, not a panic. Selling at the bottom of a crash to meet a divestment deadline turns a commitment into a loss.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Dutch crypto exchange Knaken went bankrupt with €7M of customer funds missing
Tsingshan's short squeeze broke the LME — $19.7B in margin calls, 9,000 trades cancelled
Qatar Investment Authority lost $300M on Credit Suisse — a sovereign fund's bad bet
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.