What happened
In March 2019, Masayoshi Son gathered Oyo founder Ritesh Agarwal and lieutenants from both companies in a Tokyo conference hall to plan Oyo's Japan entry. One bullet on the whiteboard caught his eye: one million rooms within a year for Oyo Life. Son had everyone sign under the goals, scrawling under 'BINDING' in all caps. The hotel team aimed for 75,000 first-year rooms, to pass the Apa chain at No.1; the apartment unit picked one million partly as 'a stunning, round number' that would top the Japanese market leader. By February 2020, Oyo Life had about 7,500 rooms — under 1% of the pledge.
Execution never caught up. HR ran up to 15 interviews a day, same-day hand-written offers; Oyo Hotels surged past 580 staff and Oyo Life added 300. But the India-built systems weren't ready: rooms were double-booked because Oyo hadn't integrated with local travel agencies, staff in India entered Japanese reservations manually, and owners saw rates cut to pennies by algorithms, with fixes taking days from India. One tenant spent the night in his car after a wrong lock-box code, with no one manning the help lines; a customer set up an 'Oyo Life Victims Association' account on Twitter.
The chaos turned legal. After hiring many staff on temporary contracts, Oyo tried to cut their salaries by up to 50% — forgetting Japanese labour law prohibits such layoffs — and withdrew the offers only after SoftBank sent compliance staff in for a week-long audit, blaming an administrative mistake. It cancelled a 100 million yen furniture order with Takumi Otsuka a month after a handshake, despite a dedicated production line already running. With hotels short of target, it launched Project Yukichi, drafting support staff into sales quotas of 30 leads a month after a three-day Bain training.
All this while Son told a SoftBank World audience, 'In three months, he will become the world's biggest hotel king. This would be a first in human history' — and, behind the scenes, personally guaranteed the $2 billion in loans that let Agarwal buy out early investors and double Oyo's valuation to $10 billion.
What it cost
Oyo Life reached about 7,500 rooms, under 1% of target; the hotel unit missed its 75,000-room goal, and its pay-cut plan broke Japanese labour law.
Why it happened
Targets were round numbers meant to beat local market leaders, not market sizes: the 1.6-million-room addressable market counted campgrounds, hostels and pay-by-the-hour love hotels.
The India playbook and India-built systems were transplanted wholesale: manual reservation entry and remote pricing control produced double bookings and ruinous rates for owners.
Hiring ran far ahead of operations, and performance management ignored Japanese labour law, forcing a humiliating reversal under SoftBank's own audit.
Son's capital and stage-craft set the pace: he pushed Agarwal to chase Marriott by room count and put his signature — literally — under a one-year, one-million-room pledge.
The lesson
Growth targets picked as round numbers to beat a market leader — rather than from real market size and local capacity — produce hiring, pricing and compliance failures faster than they produce rooms.
Aftermath
By February 2020 Son was fielding questions about Oyo at his earnings briefing, conceding 'some conflicts with hotel owners' while insisting 'Oyo is a wonderful company'. SoftBank said it believed Oyo could expand sustainably with good corporate governance. Analysts were blunter: Manhattan Venture Partners' Santosh Rao called Oyo 'a WeWork in the making' that needed 'to slow down and pull back', and Jefferies' Atul Goyal warned that with Son fundraising for a Vision Fund successor while fending off Paul Singer's activist campaign, 'if Oyo blows up, that won't be easy'.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
The sources
- Masayoshi Son's real estate bet has some big problems realty.economictimes.indiatimes.com