Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2012

Nokia's Lumia 920 launch ad was shot with a pro camera — and viewers caught the van

The OIS demo appeared to be filmed on the phone by a cyclist. Window reflections revealed a camera crew in a van. Nokia apologised within 24 hours.

Nokia · 2012-09-06

What happened

On 5 September 2012, Nokia announced the Lumia 920, its flagship Windows Phone 8 device, at an event in New York. The phone's headline feature was an 8.7-megapixel PureView camera with optical image stabilisation (OIS). To demonstrate the OIS, Nokia released a promotional video showing smooth, steady footage apparently filmed by someone riding a bicycle while holding the phone.

Within hours, viewers noticed that window reflections in the video showed a professional camera crew riding in a van alongside the cyclist. The footage had not been shot on the Lumia 920 at all. Technology blogs and social media users seized on the discrepancy, and the story spread rapidly. Nokia shares had already fallen 16% on the announcement day, as analysts found the presentation vague and lacking specific launch details.

On 6 September, Nokia issued a public apology. The company acknowledged that the OIS demonstration footage was not shot on the Lumia 920 but with professional equipment, said the video was intended only to illustrate the benefits of optical stabilisation, and admitted it 'should have been more careful.' Nokia updated the promotional material to indicate the footage was not phone-shot. Later reviews confirmed the phone's actual camera performance was comparable to what the ad had portrayed — the deception was unnecessary.

Why it happened

  • The marketing team optimised the demo for visual impact over honesty, assuming viewers would not scrutinise a 30-second clip frame by frame — but the launch audience is the people who do
  • The ad was produced to broadcast standard (crew, van, pro camera) then labelled as phone footage, erasing the line between what the phone can do and what a production team can do
  • The apology confirmed the deception without explaining why real footage was not used, implying the phone could not deliver what was promised — which later reviews disproved
What it costpublic apology; launch credibility damagedembarrassing

The lesson

A product demo that fakes the result destroys trust in the real result — if the phone's actual OIS was good enough, the staged version cost Nokia the one thing a launch needs: credibility.

Aftermath

The Lumia 920 went on to receive positive camera reviews, but the fake demo became the story that stuck. The case was widely cited in discussions about authenticity in product marketing and the risks of staging demonstrations. Nokia's broader decline continued — the Lumia line never achieved the market share needed to justify the Windows Phone bet, and Microsoft wrote off the Nokia phone business in 2015.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →