The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Strategic decision · 2000–2001
Moulinex died on 11 September 2001 — France's other September 11
El.Fi took 74 percent of Moulinex, then refused the recapitalisation; the group filed on 7 September 2001, four days before the world looked away.
Moulinex · El.Fi · Groupe SEB
HearsayWidely repeated, and we cannot show you a document for it. Read it for the lesson, not as fact.
What it means today
Before merging into a group that promises the rescue, ask who signs when the rescue is due. Moulinex gave its majority shareholder both roles; when the recapitalisation came, the refusal was unanswerable — and 5,600 jobs had no second bidder.
What happened
Moulinex, the French appliance maker that had bought Germany's Krups in 1991, went looking for European scale in 2000. In March the Italian group El.Fi — the holding company behind Brandt — took 25 percent of the capital, then 74; on 22 December 2000 the two merged into Moulinex-Brandt. The plan needed money the group did not have: when the restructuring was announced in April 2001, with six plant closures including three in France, the group's debt was at its maximum.
The rescue depended on the shareholder. El.Fi, now at 74.3 percent, refused to subscribe to the recapitalisation needed to finance the restructuring plan. On 7 September 2001 Moulinex-Brandt filed; the commercial court of Nanterre opened receivership proceedings with six months of observation. Four days later — the Tuesday that became the other September 11 — management ordered the total cessation of activity, and 5,600 employees were being dismissed.
The debt stood at seven billion francs at the moment of filing, as the Senate record put it — a disaster not without those responsible. On 22 October the Nanterre court chose Groupe SEB's offer over the American Fidei's: SEB took three quarters of Moulinex's activities, but only 1,850 employees out of 5,600; the other plants closed, and Basse-Normandie, the company's historical cradle, called it a trauma.
The collapse is still told as l'autre 11 septembre. Thierry Lepaon, the CGT delegate who represented the staff on the board, spent ten years writing its memoir — Moulinex, d'un monde à l'autre (Éd. Ouest-France, 2021): 'Two worlds were collapsing: the one we could imagine, and the industrial world with Moulinex. It is not the same tragedy, but we lived both on the same day, at the same hour.' The former employees' own phrase is double peine — two punishments, one morning.
Why it happened
- The merger made one shareholder both owner and rescue: El.Fi held 74 percent, and the restructuring plan lived or died by its signature — which never came.
- Seven billion francs of debt at filing; the April plan that closed six plants bought time the balance sheet did not have.
- The date decided the memory: the attacks of 11 September 2001 eclipsed the fall of a national industrial name, and the workers carried both at once.
The lesson
When a restructuring depends on one signature, the company has one creditor left. Moulinex's majority shareholder refused to sign — and five weeks later the group filed.
Sources
- Encyclopædia Universalis — 7 septembre–22 octobre 2001: placement de Moulinex-Brandt en redressement judiciaire (Nanterre court, six months' observation, two administrators; El.Fi at 74.3% 'avait refusé de participer à la recapitalisation'; 22 Oct: SEB chosen over Fidei, 'trois quarts des activités... mais seulement 1 850 salariés sur 5 600')
- Sénat — Question n°0544G de Jean-Pierre Godefroy, 11 octobre 2001 ('la dette de l'entreprise atteignait 7 milliards de francs au moment du dépôt de bilan'; 'un véritable traumatisme' en Basse-Normandie; four sites and ~3,000 jobs cut by the SEB offer)
- Wikipedia (fr) — Moulinex (Krups bought 1991; El.Fi enters March 2000 at 25% then 74%; Moulinex-Brandt created 22 December 2000; April 2001 plan closes six plants, three in France — Alençon, Cormelles-le-Royal, Lesquin; SEB decision 22 October 2001, 1,856 of 5,590 jobs kept)
- France 3 Normandie — L'autre 11 septembre 2001 : la chute de l'empire Moulinex (Émilie Flahaut, 10 Sept 2021: the attacks 'éclipsent la chute de Moulinex'; on that Tuesday 'la direction ordonne la cessation de toute activité... et 5600 salariés sont licenciés'; 'double peine' among former staff)
- Ouest-France — Moulinex : deux mondes qui s'effondraient (interview with Thierry Lepaon, CGT delegate and staff board representative, 10 Sept 2021: his book Moulinex, d'un monde à l'autre, Éd. Ouest-France 2021 — 'J'ai mis dix ans à écrire ce livre'; 'nous, on a vécu les deux le même jour, à la même heure')
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
A ¥6.3B rescue couldn't stop a ¥23.7B writedown at China's mall giant
Gome's founder surrendered the company to a creditor for HK$377M
A 90-year-old department store has ¥137M cash against ¥3.9B of short-term debt
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.