Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2026

Motorpoint's 'Save up to £17,000' ad banned — 1.2% of its cars qualified

An Instagram ad promised savings 'up to £17,000'; only 20 of 1,611 cars reached that band. The ASA: 'up to' claims must reflect the true picture.

Motorpoint · 2026-06-24

What happened

On 5 March 2026 Motorpoint, the UK's largest used-car supermarket, ran a paid Instagram ad: 'Why buy new? Save £1000s off nearly new used cars. Browse our wide range across 21 stores nationwide', over an image stating 'Save up to £17,000', with 'NOW ON' and 'UNBEATABLE PRICE EVENT' graphics. A carousel of 40 vehicles repeated the format.

A consumer who could not find a vehicle with a £17,000 saving complained. Motorpoint argued the claim compared its prices against the recommended retail prices of equivalent new cars, and submitted substantiation given to Clearcast in December 2025: 10.68% of its stock fell in saving bands of £19,000 or more, 52.4% in the £5,000-£9,999 range, and the most common bands were £5,000-£5,999 and £6,000-£6,999. Only 20 of 1,611 vehicles — about 1.2% — sat in the £17,000-£17,999 band.

The ASA upheld the complaint on 24 June 2026, finding breaches of CAP Code rules 3.1 (misleading advertising), 3.7 (substantiation), 3.17 and 3.22 (prices). Consumers would understand 'Save £1000s' as substantial savings available across the range, and the evidence did not show £17,000 savings on a significant proportion of vehicles. The 'up to £17,000' claim exaggerated the savings generally available. The ad must not appear again; future savings claims must reflect the true overall picture. Motorpoint accepted its terms and conditions could have been clearer.

Why it happened

  • The maths did the misleading: 1.2% of the stock could deliver the headline number, and the most common saving was a third of it
  • 'Up to £17,000' is a ceiling, not a promise — but a ceiling only 20 of 1,611 cars touch is a headline selling what the stock does not
  • Comparing against the RRP of cars it does not sell turned 'what you save' into a comparison with an imaginary alternative
What it costad banned; savings claims redoneembarrassing

The lesson

'Up to' is a promise with an asterisk. When 1.2% of stock can deliver the headline saving, the ceiling is not a claim — it is a lure, and the ASA requires the picture behind it.

Aftermath

The ad must not appear again, and Motorpoint was told to ensure future savings claims are not misleading and that 'up to £x off' claims reflect the true overall savings picture. Motor Trader and AM Online covered the ruling as a reminder for car retail that 'up to' headlines need a stock reality behind them; the company said it would add equivalent wording to future ads to reduce the risk of confusion.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →