Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Trading & Investing · Financial decision · 2021

Melvin Capital shorted GameStop — and a Reddit army squeezed it for a 53% loss in a month

In January 2021, traders on Reddit's r/wallstreetbets bet against the hedge funds that had heavily shorted GameStop. The stock went vertical; Melvin Capital.

Melvin Capital · GameStop · 2021-01

What happened

By late 2020, GameStop — a struggling video-game retailer — was one of the most heavily shorted stocks in the market: roughly 140% of its available shares had been sold short by hedge funds betting the price would fall. One of the biggest short-sellers was Melvin Capital, a prominent hedge fund. Then traders on the Reddit forum r/wallstreetbets, led by figures like Keith Gill ('Roaring Kitty'), noticed the setup and saw an opportunity.

Starting in January 2021, the forum's members began buying GameStop shares and call options en masse, urging each other to hold. As the price rose, the hedge funds that had shorted the stock were forced to buy shares to cover their positions — which pushed the price up further, in a self-reinforcing 'short squeeze.' GameStop's stock, which had traded around $20, surged to a peak above $480 in days.

The losses for short-sellers were enormous. Melvin Capital lost about 53% of its value in January alone, and survived only after a $2.75 billion rescue from rival firms Citadel and Point72. The episode triggered a political firestorm — especially after the brokerage Robinhood temporarily restricted buying of GameStop, citing clearing-house collateral requirements. Melvin never recovered; it shut down in 2022. The squeeze became a defining case of how a coordinated crowd can exploit a crowded short.

Why it happened

  • Melvin and other funds had shorted far more shares than were freely available (140% of float), creating the conditions for a violent squeeze.
  • A coordinated crowd of retail traders, organized on Reddit, deliberately targeted the crowded short and bought en masse.
  • As the price rose, short-sellers were forced to buy to cover, which drove the price higher in a self-reinforcing loop.
  • The funds underestimated both the coordination possible through social media and the unlimited downside of a short position.
What it cost53% in a month; fund closed in 2022costly

The lesson

A short position has unlimited downside, and a crowded short is a fuse. Melvin bet against a stock a coordinated crowd decided to buy, and the squeeze nearly destroyed it.

Aftermath

The GameStop short squeeze is taught as a landmark case of how social media can coordinate a crowd to exploit a crowded short, and of the unlimited risk of short selling. It triggered congressional hearings, scrutiny of brokerages and the practice of payment for order flow, and a lasting debate about market structure and retail power. Melvin Capital, despite its bailout, continued to struggle and closed in 2022. The lesson: a position that everyone is on is the most dangerous position to be on, and the crowd on the other side of your trade can move faster than you can.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →