Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Trading & Investing · Operational decision · 1996–2000

The hedge fund manager who bet against the bubble — and hid $400M in losses

Michael Berger shorted overvalued stocks during the dot-com boom. He lost $400M, hid it for three years, then jumped bail and fled to Austria.

Manhattan Investment Fund · Bear Stearns · 2000

What happened

Michael Berger was a hedge fund manager who ran the Manhattan Investment Fund during the late 1990s, betting against US technology stocks that he believed were overvalued. The strategy was a disaster: the market kept rising, and Berger's short positions kept losing money. By the time the fund collapsed, the losses totaled approximately $400 million.

Rather than reporting the losses to investors, Berger hid them for more than three years. He issued false statements showing the fund was profitable, and used new investor money to pay redemptions to earlier investors — a classic Ponzi-like structure. His prime broker, Bear Stearns, was the heavily regulated firm that enabled Berger to mislead his clients and the fund's administrator and auditor. The fraud was uncovered only when Bear Stearns itself complained to the SEC.

The SEC shut down the fund and a court-appointed trustee took control of the remaining assets. Berger was charged with securities fraud. He jumped bail and disappeared, spending five years as a fugitive before being arrested in Austria. Because he was an Austrian citizen, he was not extradited to the United States, where he would have faced a six-and-a-half-year prison term. He served almost two years in an Austrian prison. The lawsuits against Bear Stearns dragged on for years.

Why it happened

  • Berger's prime broker, Bear Stearns, was supposed to be the check on the fund's reporting — but it enabled the fraud instead of detecting it.
  • The SEC failed to catch the fraud despite the fund operating in a regulated market — the regulator did not investigate until Bear Stearns complained.
  • Investors relied on Berger's falsified statements without independent verification of the fund's holdings — a failure of due diligence compounded by the lack of a custodian checking positions.
What it cost$400M lost, fund collapsed, manager fled to Austriacostly

The lesson

A prime broker that reports what the fund tells it is not a safeguard. The fund was hidden in plain sight — the broker knew the positions, the auditor certified the numbers, and the SEC never looked.

Aftermath

The Manhattan Investment Fund fraud resembled the Madoff fraud in structure: the broker-dealer enabled the deception, the auditor failed to verify, and the regulator did not investigate until a complaint was filed. The case became a cautionary tale about the failure of the custody and reporting chain in the hedge fund industry. The lawsuits against Bear Stearns, which dragged on for years, highlighted the role of prime brokers in enabling hedge fund fraud. Berger's flight and capture in Austria added a dramatic coda to a case that regulators had missed entirely.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →