The encyclopedia · Engineering & Operations · Operational decision · 2013
Lac-Mégantic: a runaway oil train destroyed a town — 47 dead in minutes
An unattended 73-car oil train rolled 11 km downhill and exploded in Lac-Mégantic, Quebec, killing 47 and levelling the downtown core.
Montreal, Maine and Atlantic Railway · 2013-07-06
What happened
Shortly after 1:00 am on July 6, 2013, a 73-car Montreal, Maine and Atlantic Railway train carrying Bakken crude oil rolled away from where it was parked in Nantes, Quebec, 11 km west of Lac-Mégantic. With no one aboard, it accelerated to 105 km/h on a 1.2% downhill grade. At 1:14 am it derailed in the centre of Lac-Mégantic. The resulting explosion and fire destroyed 30 buildings, burned for nearly two days, and killed 47 people — most of them asleep.
The cause was a cascade of failures. The train was left unattended with only one engineer on shift. When a fire on the lead locomotive drew the Nantes fire department, firefighters shut the engine down. The air compressor stopped, brake pressure bled off, and the 7 to 11 handbrakes that had been applied were not enough to hold the train on the grade. The Transportation Safety Board concluded 17 to 26 handbrakes were needed. MMA had no rule against leaving a running train unattended on a grade near a populated area.
The disaster destroyed MMA. The railway filed for bankruptcy in August 2013. Three employees — engineer Thomas Harding, operations manager Jean DeMaître, and rail traffic controller Richard Labrie — were charged with 47 counts of criminal negligence causing death but acquitted in 2018 after a jury trial. In a second trial, six MMA employees pleaded guilty to regulatory charges. MMA subsidiary MMAC was fined $1 million for polluting the river. Canada overhauled rail safety, banned weak tank cars, and required two-person crews, but for the 47 dead the changes came too late.
Why it happened
- The train was left unattended on a downhill grade with only 7 to 11 handbrakes applied. The TSB said 17 to 26 were needed. When the engine was shut down, the air brakes bled off and the train rolled.
- MMA had no rule against leaving a running train unattended on a grade near a populated area. Its accident rate was 36.1 per million miles — more than double the national average of 14.6.
- The train hit 105 km/h in a 16 km/h zone — a runaway with 72 cars of crude oil. The derailment and fire killed 47 people, destroyed 30 buildings, and vaporised victims in the heat.
The lesson
When you park 72 cars of crude oil on a hill, you bet that 7 handbrakes are enough. Lac-Mégantic proved a railway with double the industry accident rate has no business betting on handbrakes.
Aftermath
MMA filed for bankruptcy in August 2013 and was sold to Fortress Investment Group. Three employees charged with 47 counts of criminal negligence causing death were acquitted in 2018. Six pleaded guilty to regulatory offences. Canada banned the weakest DOT-111 tank cars from crude oil service, required two-person crews, and strengthened dangerous-goods rules. Railways stopped leaving unattended locomotives on main lines. A $60M provincial fund was created for survivors; cleanup cost over $200M. But 47 people died because one railway thought 7 handbrakes on a downgrade was acceptable.
Sources
- Wikipedia — Lac-Mégantic rail disaster (July 6, 2013; 73-car MMA oil train; 11 km runaway; 105 km/h derailment; 47 dead; 7-11 handbrakes vs 17-26 needed; MMA bankruptcy; Canada rail safety reforms)
- BBC News
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
A routine upgrade at Rogers took down Canada's networks for 19 hours — 911 went with it
Wenzhou train collision — signal failure killed 40, froze China's rail expansion
Quebec Bridge collapsed during construction — 1907 and again in 1916 — killing 88
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.