Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Engineering & Operations · Strategic decision · 1858–2001

Johns-Manville knew asbestos killed — hid it for 50 years, 16,500 suits, then Ch.11

Johns-Manville, the largest US asbestos maker, hid the known link to cancer for 40 years. 16,500 lawsuits, Ch.11 1982.

Johns-Manville Corporation · Manville Corporation · 1982-08

What happened

Johns-Manville was founded in 1858 by Henry Ward Johns in New York as H.W. Johns Manufacturing Company, producing asbestos-based roofing and insulation. In 1901 it merged with Charles Manville's competing firm to become H.W. Johns-Manville Company. By the mid-20th century it was the largest asbestos manufacturer in the United States, producing asbestos pipe insulation, roofing, cement pipe, and fireproofing materials used in millions of buildings, ships, and factories. Its products made it one of the most successful industrial companies in America.

But Johns-Manville knew the truth almost from the start. As early as 1929, employees filed disability claims for lung disease. In 1943, the Saranac Laboratory confirmed a direct link between asbestos exposure and cancer. Johns-Manville suppressed the report and never warned its workers or customers. It maintained a deliberate policy of not telling employees their X-rays showed asbestosis — leaving them to work with the lethal fiber until they died. Internal documents later revealed a systematic cover-up led by company lawyer Vandiver Brown.

By 1982, 16,500 personal injury lawsuits were pending. In June 1982, James Cavett won a $2.3M compensatory and $1.5M punitive verdict. Two months later, Johns-Manville filed Ch.11 — the largest US bankruptcy at the time. The company emerged in 1988 as Manville Corporation, transferring most equity to the Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust. The trust, funded with ~$2.5B in stock and insurance proceeds, has paid hundreds of thousands of claims but repeatedly cut payout percentages. Berkshire Hathaway acquired the company in 2001. The trust still operates today.

Why it happened

  • Johns-Manville knew by 1943 that asbestos caused cancer but suppressed the Saranac Lab report and never warned workers or customers — selling the deadly product for 40 more years.
  • The company maintained a policy from the 1930s of not telling employees their X-rays showed asbestosis, letting them continue working with the lethal fiber until they died.
  • 16,500 lawsuits were pending by August 1982. The company filed Ch.11 — the largest US bankruptcy at the time — to cap liability rather than compensate its victims.
  • The $3B+ Manville Trust was created in 1988 to pay claimants but has repeatedly cut payouts as claims kept arriving, leaving victims with pennies on the dollar.
What it cost100K+ dead/yr; 16,500 suits; Ch.11 1982; $3B trustcatastrophic

The lesson

A company that knows its product kills and hides the evidence is not making a mistake — it is committing a crime. Johns-Manville did exactly that for 40 years.

Aftermath

Johns-Manville emerged from Chapter 11 in 1988 as Manville Corporation. The Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust, funded with ~$2.5B in cash, bonds, and stock, has paid hundreds of thousands of claims but by the 2000s was paying roughly 10 cents on the dollar. The company renamed itself Johns Manville in 1997 and was acquired by Berkshire Hathaway in 2001. The trust still operates today. The case set the precedent for dozens of other asbestos companies to use Chapter 11 for mass-tort liability. Asbestos kills ~100,000+ people globally each year.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →