Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Engineering & Operations · Technical decision · 2011-2021

Hyundai and Kia's Theta II engine: metal debris, then a $1.3B settlement

Debris left in Theta II engines at Hyundai's Alabama plant starved connecting-rod bearings of oil, causing seizures and fires across millions of cars.

Hyundai Motor · Kia Corporation · 2017

What happened

Hyundai's Theta II GDI engine, built at the company's Alabama plant and shared with Kia's Optima, Sorento and Sportage, was assembled with metallic manufacturing debris left inside the block near the crankshaft. The debris blocked oil flow to the connecting-rod bearings, starving them of lubrication.

Under-lubricated bearings wore down and could cause the connecting rod to seize or, in some cases, punch through the engine block, leaking oil that could ignite and start a fire. A knocking noise was the main warning sign available to drivers before failure.

Hyundai issued an initial, limited recall in 2015 and expanded it in 2017 as Kia joined the recall effort for its shared-engine models; further expansions followed through 2018 as regulators and litigation pushed the scope wider. In May 2021 a federal court granted final approval of a $1.3 billion class-action settlement covering roughly 1.05 million Hyundai and 1.16 million Kia vehicles from model years 2011 to 2018, providing a lifetime engine warranty, a knock-sensor detection software update, and reimbursement for repairs and lost value.

Why it happened

  • Manufacturing debris was never fully cleared from finished Theta II engine blocks at Hyundai's Alabama plant, and the quality-control gap wasn't caught before millions of engines shipped.
  • Hyundai's first recall in 2015 covered only a fraction of the affected cars; Kia's shared engine wasn't added until 2017, and further expansions kept coming for years afterward.
What it cost$1.3B settlement; 2.1M+ vehicles recalledcatastrophic

The lesson

A recall that expands three more times over six years means the first recall never found the real scope of the defect — each expansion admitted the last one wasn't enough.

Aftermath

The 2021 settlement provided a lifetime warranty against the engine defect and knock-sensor software to detect bearing wear before failure, but further engine-fire complaints led to additional NHTSA investigations and a later settlement covering another 2.1 million vehicles, extending the automakers' engine-fire liability years past the original 2015 recall.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →