Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 1998–2010

Fiat launched the most practical small car in Europe — and buried it because it was ugly

The Multipla had six seats in four metres, a flat floor, and a face only a mother could love. Fiat redesigned the face in 2004 and killed the car in 2010.

Fiat

HearsayWidely repeated, and we cannot show you a document for it. Read it for the lesson, not as fact.

What it means today

Every product that looks different will be mocked before it is copied. The Multipla pattern: the market ridicules the design, the company redesigns to look normal, and a competitor ships the same idea with a conventional face three years later.

What happened

The Fiat Multipla, launched in 1998, was an engineering solution to a real problem: how to fit six seats, a flat load floor, and a panoramic driving position into a car shorter than four metres. The answer was a two-tier front end — a roll of bodywork below the windshield that housed the headlights and a second set of indicators. The car was widely mocked. Top Gear named it the ugliest car ever made.

Underneath the controversy, the Multipla was genuinely innovative. It offered six individual seats in a compact footprint, a raised driving position that predated the SUV boom by a decade, and a flat floor that made the interior feel twice its size. Owners loved it. The motoring press could not stop talking about the face.

In 2004 Fiat redesigned the front end to look conventional. The car's sales, which had been modest but steady, declined. Production ended in 2010. The Multipla's engineering ideas — compact MPV packaging, raised seating, flexible interiors — were adopted by every manufacturer within five years. The car that invented the category was forgotten; the category it invented became the industry standard.

Why it happened

  • Fiat let the design controversy define the product: the engineering was the story, but the face became the story. The company never made the press talk about the six seats instead of the headlights
  • The 2004 redesign conceded that the car was wrong. Making it conventional validated the mockery and removed the car's only visual identity — the thing that made it memorable
  • The car was ahead of its market: compact MPVs became the dominant European body style by 2010, but in 1998 the market expected small cars to look small. Right idea, five years too early
What it cost12-year run ended; category invented, brand forgottenembarrassing

The lesson

If your product is genuinely new, the first reaction will be ridicule. The question is not whether the market will accept the idea — it will, in five years — but whether you can survive the laughter.

Aftermath

The Multipla's packaging concepts were adopted by the Renault Scénic, the Citroën C4 Picasso, and eventually by the SUV boom. The car itself became a cult object; clean examples now command collector prices. Fiat's subsequent compact MPV, the 500L, used the Multipla's raised-seating concept with a conventional face.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →