Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Financial decision · 2000–2005

Fiat nearly went bankrupt on a car business that burned €1B a year

Fiat Auto was bleeding cash, so in 2000 Fiat sold GM a 20% stake for $2.4B plus a put option. When GM tried to exit, Fiat forced a €1.55B ($2B) payout.

Fiat · 2005-02

What happened

For a century Fiat was Italy's industrial flagship, but by the late 1990s its car division was in trouble. Weak models, quality problems and too many brands left Fiat Auto unprofitable. By 2000 it was burning through more than €1 billion of cash a year, and the group carried roughly €5 billion in net liabilities.

Needing a lifeline, Fiat struck a deal with General Motors in 2000: GM bought 20% of Fiat Auto for $2.4 billion, and the two set up joint ventures. Crucially, Fiat also won a put option — the right to force GM to buy the rest of Fiat Auto. It was an unusual clause, and it became Fiat's most valuable asset.

Fiat's crisis deepened through 2002 to 2004 and the group came close to collapse. When Fiat later moved to exercise the put, GM refused, arguing that a recapitalisation that had halved its stake to 10% had invalidated the option. The two sides headed for court.

In February 2005 they settled. GM paid Fiat €1.55 billion (about $2 billion) to terminate the agreement — cancelling the put, unwinding the joint ventures and returning its 10% stake. The cash and the freedom to restructure on its own bought Fiat time; under Sergio Marchionne, who took over in 2004, the carmaker returned to profit and later acquired Chrysler.

Why it happened

  • Fiat Auto lost money for years because weak products, quality problems and an over-broad brand portfolio left it unable to cover its costs.
  • The business burned more than €1 billion of cash a year against roughly €5 billion of net liabilities, so survival depended on outside capital rather than its own earnings.
  • Selling a stake to GM was a financing move of last resort; the only thing Fiat kept that mattered was the put option that could force GM to buy the rest.
  • When GM tried to escape the put, Fiat's leverage was a single contract clause — the difference between a forced sale and a €1.55 billion cash settlement.
What it costnear-bankruptcy; the car stake sold to GMcostly

The lesson

When a business survives on a lifeline rather than its own earnings, the terms of the lifeline become its most important asset. Fiat's put option — not its cars — is what saved it.

Aftermath

Marchionne cut costs, revived the products and used the breathing room to orchestrate Fiat's 2009 takeover of Chrysler, creating Fiat Chrysler Automobiles. The GM settlement is taught as a case in distressed negotiation: a weak company holding one strong contractual right can extract far more than its business is worth, and a buyer that under-prices an option can pay billions to escape it.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →