Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Financial decision · 2016–2017

Etihad bought stakes in failing airlines to build a network — and wrote down $1.87B

Etihad bought minority stakes in Air Berlin, Alitalia and Jet Airways to ring Abu Dhabi with partners. All three failed; its 2016 loss was $1.87 billion.

Etihad Airways · 2017

What happened

From the mid-2000s, under chief executive James Hogan, Etihad Airways of Abu Dhabi built its network by buying stakes in other airlines. Rather than fly every route itself, it took non-controlling positions in carriers including Air Berlin, Alitalia, Jet Airways and Virgin Australia, intending to feed traffic through its Abu Dhabi hub and turn the partners around.

The partners did not turn around. Air Berlin and Alitalia both collapsed into administration in 2017, and Jet Airways followed in 2019. Etihad had kept weaker airlines aloft with cash and support, but its stakes were too small to force the restructuring those airlines needed.

The bill arrived in Etihad's own accounts. For 2016, Etihad Aviation Group reported a net loss of $1.87 billion on revenue of $8.4 billion. Impairment charges totalled about $1.87 billion — roughly $1.06 billion on aircraft and about $808 million on assets and financial exposures to equity partners, mainly Alitalia and Air Berlin. Hogan and his finance chief departed.

Etihad later made a payment of more than €300 million to settle a legal dispute tied to Alitalia, and the equity alliance — Hogan's signature strategy — was reviewed and unwound. The lesson was structural: a portfolio of minority stakes in weak partners meant Etihad absorbed their losses without ever holding the control that could have prevented them.

Why it happened

  • Etihad took non-controlling stakes, so it could prop up the partners with cash but could not force the restructuring that would have made them viable
  • An equity alliance is only as strong as its weakest member; when Air Berlin, Alitalia and Jet Airways failed, Etihad's stakes were written down with them
  • The strategy imported other airlines' losses into Etihad's own accounts — about $808 million of the 2016 impairments were tied to equity-partner exposures
  • Feeding traffic through a hub does not fix a partner's cost base; the network benefits Etihad hoped for never offset the losses it absorbed
What it cost$1.87B net loss; stakes written downcostly

The lesson

A minority stake buys influence you can't use and losses you fully absorb. Etihad owned pieces of weak airlines but controlled none — it inherited their failures without the lever to prevent them.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →