Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Financial decision · 2020

Baoshang Bank was a shareholder's ATM — until the state pulled the plug

On May 24, 2019 China seized Baoshang Bank, its first bank takeover in 20 years; by Nov 23, 2020 it was in bankruptcy with a ¥140B hole.

Baoshang Bank · 2020-11-23

What happened

On 24 May 2019 the People's Bank of China and the banking regulator seized Baoshang Bank — the central bank's first such takeover in 20 years — citing serious credit risks, and appointed China Construction Bank to run its operations for a year. The bank, with 4.73 million customers, had not published an annual report since 2016; at the end of that year its outstanding loans stood at 156.5 billion yuan, a jump of 65 per cent in two years.

The cause sat in the ownership. Tomorrow Group held an 89 per cent controlling stake and, between 2005 and 2019, the bank extended 156 billion yuan of loans to Tomorrow affiliates — none of it repaid. By the end of 2019 the bank was 140 billion yuan in the red.

The resolution drew the line between who the state protects and who pays. Personal deposits were guaranteed in full — the first real use of the Deposit Insurance Fund created in 2015 — and large institutional creditors received about a 90 per cent guarantee on average, against less than 60 per cent without state funding. A new bank, Mengshang, took over the Inner Mongolia business; four out-of-region branches went to Huishang Bank; the central bank injected 23.5 billion yuan to keep deposit liquidity flowing.

In August 2020 the central bank announced the bank would be declared bankrupt; the regulator agreed on 12 November, and on 23 November 2020 the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People's Court accepted the bankruptcy liquidation case — the first bankruptcy of a commercial bank in China. The seizure had already repriced the whole system: large lenders shunned smaller banks' paper, regional lenders like Bank of Jinzhou struggled to fund themselves, and the central bank pushed 500 billion yuan into small banks via its lending facility in June 2019.

Why it happened

  • The 89% controlling shareholder treated the bank as its own treasury: 156 billion yuan of loans to Tomorrow affiliates between 2005 and 2019, none repaid.
  • By end-2019 the hole was 140 billion yuan — too deep for the deposit base, too connected to be quietly wound down.
  • The state chose to break the implicit guarantee: personal deposits protected, large creditors haircut, and the bank sent to bankruptcy.
What it costbankrupt; ¥140B hole; first such bankruptcycatastrophic

The lesson

Implicit guarantees end the day the state lets one bank fail. Baoshang's bankruptcy taught China's money market to price risk — and small banks paid for the lesson in funding.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →