The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2010–2014
Vancl grew 300% a year, set a 10-billion target, and drowned in stock
China's hottest online fashion brand expanded to 300 product lines and 13,000 staff in four years. The IPO never came. The inventory never left.
Vancl · 2011-03
What happened
Chen Nian founded Vancl (凡客诚品) in Beijing in 2007, initially selling men's shirts online. The brand grew explosively: 2010 revenue exceeded 2 billion yuan, up 300 percent year on year, driven by 29-yuan printed T-shirts and a viral advertising campaign featuring writer Han Han and actress Wang Luodan. The ad copy style became a national meme known as 凡客体. Vancl's valuation reached 3 billion dollars.
In March 2011, Chen Nian set a revenue target of 10 billion yuan for the year — five times the previous year's actual. To chase it, Vancl expanded from shirts into 300 product lines spanning women's clothing, shoes, home goods and accessories. The workforce swelled to 13,000. The company raised over 500 million dollars across multiple funding rounds.
The target was never close. By the end of 2011, Vancl sat on 1.4 billion yuan of unsold inventory and had accumulated nearly 600 million yuan in losses. The planned IPO was shelved. Over the next three years the company sold its logistics arm Rufengda Express, its V+ third-party platform, and its warehousing operations. By 2016 it was left with a single struggling online mall, kept alive by a 100-million-dollar rescue round led by Lei Jun.
Vancl attempted a reset focused on basic items — T-shirts and shirts benchmarked against Uniqlo — but the brand never recovered its position. The company that had been China's most valuable online fashion retailer became a case study in what happens when a growth target replaces a business plan.
Why it happened
- The 10-billion-yuan target was set by multiplying the previous year's growth rate forward without asking whether the market or the supply chain could deliver five times the volume
- Expanding from shirts to 300 product lines meant Vancl was no longer a shirt company with a brand — it was an inventory company with a marketing budget, and the inventory did not sell
- The viral 凡客体 campaign created brand awareness far beyond the supply chain's ability to fulfil, so demand spiked in categories where Vancl had no sourcing expertise
- A 3-billion-dollar valuation and 500 million in funding removed the discipline that a smaller capital base would have imposed: there was always money for the next expansion
The lesson
A growth rate is not a strategy. Vancl's 300 percent year was a spike, not a trajectory. The target assumed it was the baseline, and the organisation built itself for a company five times its size.
Aftermath
Vancl survived as a small online retailer selling basic shirts. Chen Nian remained as head. The case is cited in Chinese business schools alongside other vertical-ecommerce failures of the 2011 era as an example of capital-fuelled overexpansion.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
A mooncake scandal shrank Crazy Brother Yang's ¥1bn livestream empire to ¥250k streams
Knocked back ten years: Pou Sheng's Nike and Adidas trap
Pinduoduo posted its first annual profit decline — paying to win merchants back
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.