Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1999–2001

Sephora opened in Ginza in 1999 with 40-store plans — it closed all 7 stores in 2001

Its Japan debut in 1999 targeted 40 stores. After $50M+ in losses, it closed all 7 stores by 2001 — a format that worked in Paris and New York failed in Tokyo.

Sephora · LVMH · 2001-11

What happened

Sephora, the French cosmetics retailer owned by LVMH, opened its first Japanese store in Tokyo's Ginza district in November 1999 — a 10,300-square-foot, three-level beauty emporium that was the brand's bet on one of the world's largest beauty markets. The company planned 40 stores across Japan within five years.

By November 2001, Sephora announced it would close all seven of its Japanese stores by the end of the year. The $50 million-plus failure was one of the fastest exits by a major international retailer in Japan. The problems were structural: the fragrance-heavy model had little appeal in a market where fragrance made up just 2–3% of beauty sales; premium brands like Chanel, Lancôme, and YSL refused to supply the self-service retailer; and Japanese consumers, accustomed to beauty consultants at department store counters, found the 'try it yourself' format confusing rather than liberating.

Sephora president Jeff Daggett blamed the 'continuing economic downturn' in Japan, but analysts pointed to deeper issues: poor merchandise variety, unattractive pricing, and a format that had no natural advantage over Japan's drugstores, specialty stores, and department stores. The exit was the first market withdrawal in Sephora's history, predating later exits from Hong Kong, Vietnam, Taiwan, and Korea.

Why it happened

  • Sephora's fragrance-heavy retail model was a poor fit for Japan, where fragrance accounted for only 2–3% of beauty sales — the smallest share of any major beauty market.
  • Premium brands (Chanel, Lancôme, YSL) refused to supply Sephora's self-service format, treating department store counters as the only appropriate channel. Sephora's shelves were never full.
  • Japanese consumers in 1999 were accustomed to buying cosmetics with a beauty consultant at a department store counter. Sephora's self-service model confused shoppers rather than attracting them.
  • The Japanese economy was in a severe post-bubble downturn, making it the worst time to launch an expensive unfamiliar retail format that needed 40 stores to achieve scale.
What it cost~$50M+ in losses; full market exit after 2 yearscostly

The lesson

A format that wins in one market is not a universal key. When the local customer's habits, the brand-supply structure, and the category itself are all different, the global playbook is a liability.

Aftermath

Sephora did not return to Japan. The brand focused on the US and Europe, where its self-service model had already proven successful. Japan became the first of several Asian exits for Sephora: Hong Kong (2010), Vietnam (2022), Taiwan (2023), and Korea (2024). The Japan failure was also a lesson for other Western retailers entering Japan — Boots UK had also withdrawn within five years, and the pattern of format-driven failures in Japan was becoming well known.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →