Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2020

The Richards Group founder called a Motel 6 pitch 'too Black' — five clients walked

Stan Richards, founder of a top US ad agency, called a pitch 'too Black.' Five clients walked — including 34-year partner Motel 6 and 25-year Home Depot.

The Richards Group

What happened

In September 2020, Stan Richards — the 88-year-old founder of The Richards Group, one of the largest independent advertising agencies in the United States — reviewed a creative pitch for a Motel 6 campaign. He dismissed it as 'too Black,' a comment that became public and triggered immediate backlash from clients and staff.

The client exodus was swift and devastating. Motel 6, a client for 34 years, left within days. Home Depot, a 25-year client, followed. Keurig Dr Pepper, H-E-B, and Spoetzl Brewery (Shiner Bock) all departed by late October. The agency that had built its reputation on long-tenured client relationships lost five cornerstone accounts in two weeks.

On October 15, 2020, Richards announced he was stepping down, stating 'I am firing myself.' Glenn Dady, who had been named successor in a December 2019 succession plan, took over as CEO. In 2022, the agency rebranded from 'The Richards Group' to 'TRG' to distance itself from its founder, overhauled its leadership structure, and hired its first Chief Creative Officer and Chief Talent and Cultural Officer.

Why it happened

  • The comment exposed the worldview: 'too Black' told clients exactly how the founder evaluated creative — they could not stay with an agency whose bar included race.
  • The client tenure made the loss permanent: Motel 6 (34 years) and Home Depot (25 years) were not replaceable — decades-long partnerships ended by one comment.
  • The succession did not undo the brand: rebranding to TRG in 2022 confirmed the founder's name had become a liability — the agency erased its own identity to survive.
  • The timing compounded it: in the months after George Floyd's murder, 'too Black' could not be contextualised — every client had to act.
What it cost5 major clients lost; founder forced out; agency rebrandedembarrassing

The lesson

When a founder calls a campaign 'too Black,' clients hear that creative is being filtered by race. No 34-year client relationship survives that — rebranding the agency is the consequence.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →