The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2021
Peloton's viral Mr. Big ad was pulled the day the allegations broke
Peloton stopped promoting its Chris Noth ad within hours of the allegations — and archived every related social post the same day.
Peloton · Chris Noth (actor) · 2021-12-16
What happened
In early December 2021 Peloton aired a parody response to the And Just Like That episode that killed off Mr. Big: Chris Noth, as Big, wakes from the workout that killed him and tells instructor Jess King, "I feel great. Shall we take another ride? Life is too short not to." The spot was built in 48 hours in a New York studio with Ryan Reynolds' Maximum Effort agency, and went viral as the show's own buzz peaked.
On December 16, the Hollywood Reporter published allegations against Noth from two women, describing assaults in Los Angeles in 2004 and New York in 2015. Peloton removed the ad the same day, with a statement: "Every single accusation must be taken seriously. We were unaware of these allegations when we featured Chris Noth in our response to HBO's reboot. As we seek to learn more, we have stopped promoting this video and archived related social posts." Reynolds also removed the ad from his social media that day.
Four days later, CBS and Universal Television fired Noth from The Equalizer with a joint statement: "Chris Noth will no longer film additional episodes of The Equalizer, effective immediately." Peloton declined to say what the campaign had cost — the joke it had built in 48 hours was gone within one news cycle.
Why it happened
- The ad's entire value depended on the joke being in good faith — a response built in 48 hours to a scene that had gone viral had no second take.
- The statement did two things at once: took every accusation seriously and explained the brand had been unaware — no defense of the casting, no apology for the ad itself.
- The pull was the fast part; the firing four days later showed the story was bigger than one campaign.
The lesson
A joke ad has a half-life of one news cycle — when the man in the joke is accused at the ad's peak, the brand's only move is to archive the joke and say so plainly.
Aftermath
Peloton declined to say what it spent on the spot, and the market did not punish the pull — shares were up nearly 4% on the day. The ad's co-creator Ryan Reynolds removed it from his own social media, and CBS and Universal Television fired Noth from The Equalizer four days after the allegations were published. The episode became the reference for how fast a carefully engineered viral moment can reverse on a brand.
Sources
- CNBC — Peloton removes viral Chris Noth ad after allegations, 16 Dec 2021 (same-day pull; Peloton statement verbatim; Hollywood Reporter as source; Reynolds removal; stock)
- CBS News — Chris Noth pulled from CBS' "The Equalizer" amid allegations, Dec 2021 (Universal Television/CBS joint statement verbatim)
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Peloton's holiday ad was mocked as dystopian — and a rival gin brand turned it into a joke
Peloton scrubbed its new campaign face after a resurfaced high school photo
US law firm copied NZ's Cannes-winning road-safety ad — plagiarism backlash
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.