The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · Aesop
Aesop's miller changed the plan for every passer-by — and lost the donkey
The miller tried walking, riding and carrying the donkey to satisfy critics. The crowd still laughed, and the donkey fell into the river.
Aesop's miller
From historyHistory and classical literature, legend included. An analogy to think with, not a modern precedent.
What it means today
A company taking product direction from every loud comment, analyst note or internal objection can end up carrying the donkey. The discipline is not ignoring feedback; it is deciding whose feedback can change the route.
What happened
In the Aesop fable, a miller and his son set out for market with a donkey they hoped to sell. They walked beside it to keep it in good condition, until travellers mocked them for walking when one of them could ride.
The miller put his son on the donkey. Merchants then scolded the boy for riding while his father walked, so the miller rode instead. Women then scolded the father for making the boy walk, so both climbed on. Another group accused them of overloading the animal.
Trying to satisfy the latest critic, the miller and his son tied the donkey to a pole and carried it. A crowd gathered, laughed and shouted. As they crossed a bridge, the ropes gave way and the donkey fell into the river. The miller had pleased nobody and lost the asset he was trying to sell.
Why it happened
- The miller treated each passer-by as the customer, even though none of them was buying the donkey. The real buyer at market disappeared from the decision
- Every adjustment optimized for the last comment, not for the trip. The plan had no stable principle that could survive criticism
- The final compromise was worse than any earlier option. Carrying the donkey satisfied the complaint about burdening it while creating a ridiculous operating risk
- Public feedback was noisy but not accountable. The people laughing at the bridge did not bear the cost when the donkey fell
The lesson
Do not redesign a plan around every passer-by. Decide whose judgment matters before the crowd starts talking, or the loudest non-customer will run the trip.
Aftermath
The fable is commonly summarized as: if you try to please all, you please none. Its operating lesson is narrower: feedback has to be weighted by stake, expertise and accountability before it changes the plan.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Arcadia Group owned Topshop and Burton — administration in 2020 closed all stores
Starbucks opened six stores in Israel — all closed within two years
The fisherman freed the jinni from the bottle — and the jinni tried to kill him for it
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.