Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 1985–1990

McDonald's McDLT split its burger in two boxes — the planet hated the packaging

McDonald's 1985 McDLT kept hot and cool apart in a dual-compartment styrofoam clamshell. The environment could not swallow it — the burger died in 1990.

McDonald's · 1985

What happened

The McD.L.T. — short for McDonald's Lettuce and Tomato — was a hamburger launched by McDonald's in 1985. What set it apart was its packaging: a dual-compartment styrofoam clamshell that kept the patty and bottom bun on one side (the 'hot side') and the lettuce, tomato, cheese, pickles, sauces, and top bun on the other (the 'cool side'). Consumers assembled the burger themselves just before eating, ensuring a hot patty and crisp vegetables in every bite. McDonald's patented the design (US4653685A) and backed it with a memorable tagline: 'Keep the hot side hot and the cool side cool.'

The burger was promoted with high-profile television commercials featuring a young Jason Alexander (before Seinfeld made him a star), Aretha Franklin, Jerry Butler, and Janet Hubert. The product was available across the United States and seemed to have strong brand support from McDonald's. But the dual-compartment container had a hidden cost: it was made entirely of styrofoam, and environmental opposition to disposable styrofoam packaging was mounting in the late 1980s.

In 1990 — after just five years on the market — McDonald's discontinued the McDLT. The culprit was not the burger itself but the packaging: environmental concerns about styrofoam's impact on landfills and the ozone layer made the oversized clamshell untenable. McDonald's was under growing pressure from environmental groups to eliminate styrofoam, and the McDLT's distinctive box was the most visible target. Rather than redesign the packaging, the company dropped the product entirely.

Why it happened

  • The McDLT was built around a styrofoam package that became an environmental liability — the very feature that made it unique also made it unsustainable
  • McDonald's could not reformulate the product without the dual-compartment design, leaving no option but to kill the burger when the packaging had to go
  • The product solved a problem (soggy lettuce) that most customers did not care enough about to justify the extra packaging waste and cost
What it costMcDLT killed after 5 years; McDonald's phased out styrofoamembarrassing

The lesson

A product built on packaging the planet cannot absorb has an expiration date. The feature that makes it different is also the thing that limits its life.

Aftermath

McDonald's phased out styrofoam clamshell packaging entirely in 1990 under pressure from environmental groups. The McDLT was not reissued in alternative packaging. The burger has since become a nostalgia item, with celebrities like Al Roker publicly wishing for its return. It is frequently cited in lists of discontinued McDonald's products and remembered more for its packaging innovation than for the burger itself.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →