Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1997–2016

Lionhead made Fable and Black & White — Microsoft closed it after forcing Kinect

Peter Molyneux's Lionhead was bought by Microsoft in 2006 for its RPG pedigree — a decade later Kinect games and a doomed free-to-play project killed it.

Lionhead Studios · Microsoft · Bullfrog Productions · 2016-04-29

What happened

Lionhead Studios was founded in July 1997 by Peter Molyneux, Mark Webley, Tim Rance, and Steve Jackson — a breakaway from Bullfrog Productions, which Molyneux had sold to Electronic Arts. The studio became famous for ambitious, genre-blending games: Black & White (2001), a god game that won multiple BAFTAs, and the Fable series, an action RPG franchise that sold millions. At its peak around 2005, Lionhead employed roughly 220 people across its main studio and satellite teams.

Molyneux was notorious for over-promising features that never shipped. Black & White was meant to have an advanced creature AI that could learn any behaviour — the final game delivered far less. Fable was advertised with features (growing old in real time, planting acorns that became trees) that were cut before release. This culture of feature creep — what staff called 'Molyneux's ambition exceeding delivery' — built every Lionhead project on an unrealistic foundation from the start.

After Black & White 2 and The Movies underperformed financially, Lionhead sought a buyer in 2006. Microsoft won the acquisition over Ubisoft, paying an undisclosed sum to secure Fable as an Xbox exclusive. But Microsoft then steered Lionhead away from its core RPG strength: it pushed the studio to make Fable: The Journey (2012), a Kinect game that was a commercial disaster, and later insisted on a games-as-a-service model for Fable Legends that Lionhead had no experience with. Co-founder Steve Jackson and several key developers left, founding Media Molecule and other studios.

In March 2016, Microsoft cancelled Fable Legends and announced plans to close Lionhead. An internal attempt called Project Phoenix — a smaller-scale Fable project meant to save jobs — failed because employees found other positions before it could start. The studio closed on 29 April 2016. Microsoft's Phil Spencer later admitted: 'You acquire a studio for what they're great at now, and your job is to help them accelerate how they do what they do, not make them accelerate what you do.'

Why it happened

  • Feature creep was baked into Lionhead's culture — Molyneux promised features that were never built, inflating expectations and wasting development time on every project from Black & White to Fable.
  • Microsoft acquired Lionhead for its single-player RPG expertise, then forced it to make Kinect games — Fable: The Journey was a commercial failure that consumed years of the studio's life.
  • Microsoft insisted on a free-to-play, games-as-a-service model for Fable Legends — a business model Lionhead had zero experience with, requiring expensive new hires and a deep shift in studio culture.
  • Key talent left after the acquisition — co-founder Steve Jackson and the team that later founded Media Molecule departed, draining the creative talent that made Lionhead distinctive.
What it cost~220 jobs lost; Fable shelved; acquisition written offcatastrophic

The lesson

Acquiring a studio for its creative strength and then forcing it to build things it was never good at is not strategy — it is throwing away what you paid for.

Aftermath

Lionhead closed on 29 April 2016. Most employees were laid off or found jobs elsewhere. Fable Legends was cancelled before release. The Fable franchise went dormant until 2022, when Playground Games announced a new Fable game for Xbox Series X/S. Peter Molyneux went on to found 22cans, making experimental mobile games. Former Lionhead staff founded or joined studios including Media Molecule (LittleBigPlanet, Dreams), The Chinese Room (Everybody's Gone to the Rapture), and Epic Games.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →