The encyclopedia · Engineering & Operations · Operational decision · 2013
Lac-Mégantic: a train with 7 hand brakes rolled away and killed 47 people
An unattended oil train with few hand brakes rolled into Lac-Mégantic. 47 died. Half of downtown gone. The railway was charged with 47 counts of negligence.
Montreal, Maine and Atlantic Railway · 2013-07-06
What happened
On 6 July 2013, an unattended 73-car Montreal, Maine and Atlantic Railway freight train carrying Bakken crude oil rolled down a 1.2% grade from Nantes, Quebec, and derailed in the centre of Lac-Mégantic. The engineer had set only 7 to 11 hand brakes before leaving the train unattended on the main line — a minimum of 17 to 26 were needed. The lead locomotive had a defective engine that had been repaired with epoxy, which failed and caused a fire that led firefighters to shut down the engine, disabling the air brake system.
As air leaked from the brake system, the hand brakes — already too few — could not hold the 9,400-tonne train on the grade. The train rolled unchecked for 11 kilometres, reaching 105 km/h before derailing in a sharp curve in the centre of town. The resulting explosions and fire destroyed over 30 buildings, roughly half the downtown core. 47 people were killed. The fire burned for nearly two days.
The Transportation Safety Board identified 18 distinct causes and contributing factors, including weak regulatory oversight by Transport Canada, which permitted single-person train operation with no rules against leaving a train carrying dangerous goods unattended on a slope. The railway was charged with 47 counts of criminal negligence. CEO Edward Burkhardt faced widespread condemnation. The disaster led to major changes in the regulation of dangerous goods transport by rail in North America.
Why it happened
- The engineer set only 7-11 hand brakes when 17-26 were needed. The lead locomotive had a defective engine repaired with epoxy. Firefighters shut it, disabling the air brakes. The train rolled away.
- 47 people died. Half of downtown Lac-Mégantic was destroyed. The railway was charged with 47 counts of criminal negligence. The cleanup cost $200M.
The lesson
A train carrying 73 cars of crude oil with only 7 hand brakes holding it on a slope is not a parked train — it is a bomb. Lac-Mégantic's 47 dead were the price of weak brakes and weak regulation.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Connacher built Canada's costliest oil sands and the oil crash took it all
A copy-paste error in a spreadsheet cost TransAlta $24 million in a power bid
Spain and Portugal went dark for a day when the Iberian grid lost voltage control
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.