Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2013

JPMorgan invited the internet to #AskJPM — and canceled the Q&A in a day

November 2013: JPMorgan asked users to send questions with #AskJPM before a Twitter Q&A. It got foreclosure jokes and fines instead — and pulled the event.

JPMorgan Chase · 2013-11

What happened

JPMorgan Chase announced a Twitter Q&A: vice chairman James B. Lee Jr. — the bank's top dealmaker, who had worked closely on Twitter's own IPO — would take over @JPMorgan on Thursday, 14 November 2013 to answer questions submitted under #AskJPM. The bank had paid more than $30 billion in fines and legal settlements since 2009, from the London Whale trading loss to foreclosure practices, and it was inviting the internet to converse.

The hashtag filled up on Wednesday afternoon. Some tweets mocked the premise itself — 'Do you think maybe this whole #ASKJPM idea was not well thought out?' Others went straight for the record: '#askJPM Any plans to return illegally foreclosed homes to their rightful owners? If not, how do you justify your continued existence?' One analysis found more than two-thirds of #AskJPM tweets were negative. Before the session's scheduled start, JPMorgan called it off.

The bank's own statement became the episode's closing line: '#Badidea! Back to the drawing board!' #AskJPM became the textbook example of a hashtag hijack — an unmoderated hashtag is not a Q&A when the reputation is bad; it is an open comment section the host has to read.

Why it happened

  • An open hashtag is a channel, not a filter: invite questions with no moderation and the audience's accumulated grievances arrive all at once.
  • The format assumed goodwill — a Q&A works only when the audience accepts the premise that the brand deserves a fair hearing, and five years of fines denied JPMorgan that premise.
  • Canceling was handled with a self-deprecating joke, but the event could not be: the bank had hosted its own roasting on its own account.
What it costevent canceled; '#Badidea!'embarrassing

The lesson

Open hashtags inherit the audience's mood. When a brand carries fines and scandals, an unmoderated Q&A is not outreach — it is handing critics the microphone and the schedule.

Aftermath

JPMorgan returned to social Q&As later in more controlled formats, but #AskJPM stayed the standard citation in marketing courses for reputation-blind campaign design. The bank's legal bills continued long after the hashtag was retired.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →