The encyclopedia · Sales & Retail · Strategic decision · 2024–2025
Heytea closed 680 stores in a year — and told its staff it was done with scale games
From 4,610 stores to 3,930 in twelve months. The internal email: 'not participating in scale involution'. The franchise machine had outrun the market.
Heytea
What happened
Heytea was the brand that defined China's new tea drink category — premium fruit tea at premium prices, queues around the block, and from 2022 a franchise model that scaled it to more than 4,600 stores by October 2024. Then the category's price war arrived: competitors drove prices down, and the franchise machine kept opening stores into a market that could not absorb them.
In February 2025 Heytea did something rare for a chain at that scale: it stopped. An internal all-staff email titled 'Not participating in digital games and scale involution, returning to users and brand' paused new franchise applications and rejected the low-price war outright. The contraction that followed was steep — by October 2025 the store count had fallen to about 3,930, a net loss of roughly 680 stores in twelve months, with Shanghai and Chongqing among the cities losing outlets. More than half of the 230-plus branches of its Shenzhen operating company were deregistered.
The pivot may yet prove sound — Heytea is choosing margin over footprint while weaker chains die — but the case is the 680 stores, not the email. A franchise model measures success in openings; the incentives of franchisor, franchisee and landlord all point at more stores, and reversing that machine takes a crisis. Heytea's competitors are closing too; the category that grew on the assumption of infinite traffic is discovering the assumption was the business plan.
Why it happened
- Franchise scaling pays the franchisor for openings, not for store profitability — the machine keeps building stores past the point where any of them make money.
- A premium brand in a price war faces the worst choice: join and destroy the margin that justifies the brand, or refuse and watch the traffic go to those who did.
- 'Scale involution' is the industry's word for a race where everyone runs faster and nobody advances — exiting the race is rational, but the stores already opened do not close themselves.
The lesson
A franchise network's opening rate is not its health — if new stores dilute old ones, growth is the disease; measure same-store survival before counting openings, because the machine never stops.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Din Tai Fung lost its whole North China network when the license broke
Shangshangqian — Joker Xue's hotpot chain — closed its last store after 14 years
Häagen-Dazs closed 92 China stores in a year — and handed the rest to a tea chain
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.