The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2018
Heineken's 'Lighter is Better' ad slid a bottle past darker customers — pulled in a day
The Heineken Light ad slid a bottle past customers of color to a lighter-skinned woman, under the line 'Sometimes Lighter is Better.' Pulled within a day.
Heineken · 2018-03-27
What happened
In March 2018 Heineken ran a commercial for Heineken Light: a bartender slides a bottle down the bar, past several darker-skinned customers, and it lands in front of a noticeably fairer-skinned woman. The tagline: 'Sometimes Lighter is Better.'
The spot was online for barely a day before Chance the Rapper called it 'terribly racist' on Twitter, asking whether 'some companies are purposely putting out noticeably racist ads so they can get more views.' The criticism spread, and Heineken removed the commercial from TV and online.
The company's response conceded the failure while defending the intent: 'While we feel the ad is referencing our Heineken Light beer, we missed the mark, are taking the feedback to heart and will use this to influence future campaigns.'
Why it happened
- The ad's visual story and its copy said the same thing — lighter is better — and the tagline turned a racial visual into the punchline.
- The light-skinned payoff made the exclusion the plot: the beer literally passes over darker customers to reach her, so the message was delivered without plausible ambiguity.
- Heineken had built its brand on 'worlds apart' ads about unity, which made the miss look like a choice rather than an accident.
- One tweet from a celebrity retired the campaign in a day, showing how fast the review cycle now runs outside the agency.
The lesson
Copywriters read the line, art directors the picture; only the pair shows the story. Next to a skin-tone visual, 'lighter is better' stops being a beer pun — check the words against the image.
Aftermath
Heineken apologized, pulled the spot and promised the feedback would influence future campaigns. The episode joined Dove and Nivea as the reference cases for how a fast approval can put a racial message on air; the company kept making 'unity' advertising, and kept being asked about this one.
Sources
- NBC News, 26 March 2018 — Heineken removes 'Lighter is Better' ad following online backlash
- USA Today, 27 March 2018 — Heineken pulls 'Lighter is Better' ad after some call it 'racist'
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Cracker Barrel dropped its old man from the logo — and reversed the rebrand within a week
Wendy's floated surge pricing and the backlash forced it to swear it never would
Bud Light sent Dylan Mulvaney a personalised can — then lost the #1 US beer spot
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.