Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Software & IT · Strategic decision · 2006–2008

Toshiba spent $986M on HD DVD — then lost the format war to Blu-ray

Toshiba backed HD DVD against Sony's Blu-ray in a format war. After Warner Bros. defected in 2008, Toshiba conceded, losing $986M.

Toshiba · Microsoft · Intel · NEC · Sanyo · 2008-02-19

What happened

In 2006, Toshiba launched HD DVD, a high-definition optical disc format, competing directly against Sony's Blu-ray. The format war was reminiscent of VHS vs Betamax — two incompatible standards fighting for the same market. Toshiba had strong backing from Microsoft and Intel, while Sony had the PlayStation 3 and a broader studio coalition.

The war was decided by content deals. Sony's PlayStation 3 shipped with a built-in Blu-ray player, giving the format a massive installed-base advantage. But the decisive blow came in January 2008 when Warner Bros., the only major studio supporting both formats, announced it would release exclusively on Blu-ray. Best Buy and Netflix followed, phasing out HD DVD. Paramount had a temporary exclusive HD DVD deal, but it was not enough to reverse the momentum.

Toshiba conceded on February 19, 2008, halting production and taking a $986 million loss. The HD DVD Promotion Group dissolved the following month. The format war cost Toshiba nearly a billion dollars and demonstrated that in a format war, content and installed base matter more than technical superiority.

Why it happened

  • Sony's PlayStation 3 included a built-in Blu-ray player, giving Blu-ray a massive installed-base advantage that HD DVD could not match.
  • Warner Bros. defected to Blu-ray exclusive in January 2008, triggering a cascade of retailers and studios abandoning HD DVD.
  • Negotiations to unify the formats in 2005 failed, forcing the market to choose and guaranteeing one side would lose billions.
What it cost$986M lost; format discontinued after 2 yearscostly

The lesson

In a format war, the device people already own wins. Sony's PS3 gave Blu-ray an installed-base advantage that no studio deal could overcome, and Toshiba lost $986M learning this.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →