Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1999–2015

Dangdang was China's Amazon — it IPO'd on the NYSE, then went private at half the price

China's first online bookstore listed on the NYSE in 2010 at ~$1B. A price war with Amazon.cn and JD.com followed. Founders bought it back for less than half.

Dangdang · 2010-11

What happened

Dangdang was founded in 1999 by Peggy Yu and Li Guoqing as China's first major online bookstore — the country's answer to Amazon. The company listed on the New York Stock Exchange in November 2010, in an IPO estimated at approximately $1 billion. It was one of the first Chinese internet companies to list in the United States.

The listing coincided with the intensification of China's e-commerce price wars. In December 2010, the month after the IPO, Dangdang entered a direct price war with Amazon.cn and JD.com, particularly in books — its core category. The company that had gone public as China's Amazon was now competing against the actual Amazon, in its own market, on price.

By July 2015, the founders proposed a management buyout at $7.81 per ADS — described as less than half of its IPO value and the lowest among Chinese ADRs seeking to go private at that time. A special committee approved the buyout, and some shareholders dissented, exercising appraisal rights.

Dangdang completed its privatisation in September 2015 and delisted from the NYSE. The company that had been China's pioneering e-commerce platform was now a private company with 2,907 employees, competing in a market dominated by JD.com and Alibaba. The 'China's Amazon' story had ended not with a bang but with a buyout at half the IPO price.

Why it happened

  • Going public as 'China's Amazon' invited comparison with the actual Amazon, which entered the Chinese market and competed directly on Dangdang's core category: books
  • The December 2010 price war with Amazon.cn and JD.com, starting the month after the IPO, meant the company was spending its public-market capital on a margin-destroying competition it could not win
  • Dangdang's book-focused model could not scale into the general-merchandise platform that JD.com and Alibaba were building; the niche that had made it famous was the niche that capped it
  • The buyout at less than half the IPO value was the founders' acknowledgement that the public-market story — China's Amazon — was worth more as a narrative than as a business
What it costIPO ~$1B; bought back at <50%costly

The lesson

Being first to market is not being best at market. When the company you're compared to enters with more capital and a broader model, the niche that made you famous becomes the ceiling.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →