Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2008–2018

Caffe Bene went from 945 stores to court rehabilitation in four years

Korea's largest coffee franchise had 945 stores and a 1,400% debt ratio. It filed for court rehabilitation in 2018 with 60 billion won in debt.

Caffe Bene Co., Ltd. · Food Empire Holdings · 2018-01

What happened

Caffe Bene was founded in 2008 by Kim Sun-kwon and grew into South Korea's largest home-grown coffee franchise, with 945 stores across the country by 2014 and over 1,000 globally at its peak, including outlets in Japan, China, the United States and Southeast Asia. The chain was built on rapid store expansion, celebrity endorsements and a wide menu of coffee, waffles and bingsu (shaved ice).

The aggressive expansion came at a cost. By 2013, Caffe Bene's debt ratio stood at 665 percent; by 2015 it exceeded 1,400 percent. The company lost approximately US$32 million in 2016. An equity fund and foreign investors took control that year and repaid 70 billion won — 70 percent of the total debt — but the company continued to face financial shortages as South Korea's coffee market became saturated.

On January 12, 2018, Caffe Bene filed for court-led corporate rehabilitation with the Seoul Central District Court. The court approved the restructuring on January 25. At the time of filing, the chain had 643 stores in Korea — a drop of one-third from its peak. A 10-year repayment plan was approved in May 2018, converting 30 percent of the debt into shares and spreading the remaining 70 percent over a decade. The company exited receivership on October 11, 2018, after just nine months.

The founder's legal troubles continued. Kim Sun-kwon was later sentenced to three years in prison for defrauding investors of approximately 30 billion won in a nursing home construction project. Caffe Bene's China joint venture went bankrupt in 2023, and all Japanese stores had closed by 2018.

Why it happened

  • Rapid franchise expansion to over 1,000 stores created a fixed-cost base that required continuous growth, but the coffee market was already saturated with competing chains.
  • The debt-funded expansion model produced a 1,400% debt ratio, meaning the company owed more than 14 times what it could repay from operations.
  • A change of ownership in 2016 — an equity fund and foreign investors — could not reverse the underlying financial strain despite repaying 70% of the debt.
  • The founder's separate fraud conviction and the collapse of the China joint venture showed that the company's problems were structural, not just financial.
What it cost60B won debt; 643 stores at filing; founder jailed for fraudcostly

The lesson

A franchise built on aggressive expansion without unit profitability is a debt pyramid. When expansion stops, the debt does not.

Aftermath

Caffe Bene exited court rehabilitation in October 2018 after nine months. The founder Kim Sun-kwon was sentenced to three years in prison for investor fraud. The company's China joint venture went bankrupt in 2023. All Japanese stores had closed by 2018.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →