Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · R&D & Science · Legal decision · 1999–2004

Bristol-Myers Squibb stuffed $1.5B in inventory to fake sales — and paid $150M to settle

Bristol-Myers inflated sales by stuffing inventory to distributors. The SEC fined $150M. Execs indicted. Restated 5 years.

Bristol-Myers Squibb · 2002

What happened

Bristol-Myers Squibb, one of the world's largest pharmaceutical companies, engaged in a practice known as 'channel stuffing' — offering excess inventory to wholesalers and distributors to artificially inflate sales numbers. The company improperly booked sales that had not actually occurred, creating a significant gap between reported revenue and true demand for its products.

The scandal came to light in 2002. The SEC and the Department of Justice launched investigations into Bristol-Myers' accounting practices. The company was forced to restate its financial results for 1999 through 2001, and later restated a full five years of results in 2004. The total improperly booked revenue was estimated at over $1.5 billion.

Bristol-Myers settled with the DOJ and SEC for $150 million in 2004, and was placed under the oversight of a court-appointed monitor. Richard Lane, former head of the Pharma group, and Fred Schiff, former CFO, were indicted for federal securities violations. CEO Peter Dolan stepped down in 2006, though his departure was related to a separate dispute over the Plavix patent.

Why it happened

  • Bristol-Myers stuffed $1.5B in excess inventory to wholesalers to fake sales revenue. The company restated its results for 1999-2001 and later restated five full years.
  • The SEC fined Bristol-Myers $150M. Two executives were indicted for securities fraud. The company was placed under a court-appointed monitor.
What it cost$150M SEC fine; $1.5B revenue restated; execs indictedcatastrophic

The lesson

A pharma co that stuffs distributors with inventory is not reporting sales — it is reporting shipments. The $1.5B restatement was the gap between what Bristol-Myers booked and what patients bought.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →