The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1959
BMW was hours from being sold to Mercedes in 1959 — a dealer's speech saved the company
In December 1959, BMW's shareholders were about to approve a takeover by Mercedes. A dealer named Herbert Quandt stood up and said no. BMW survived.
BMW
HearsayWidely repeated, and we cannot show you a document for it. Read it for the lesson, not as fact.
What it means today
Every company about to be acquired for its assets — its patents, its real estate, its customer list — faces the BMW 1959 question: is the company worth more dead or alive? The answer depends on whether someone bets on the people.
What happened
By 1959, BMW was bankrupt in all but name. The company's post-war strategy — luxury cars (the 501/502 'Baroque Angel') and microcars (the Isetta) — had failed. The luxury cars were too expensive for the post-war market; the microcars were too cheap to make a profit. BMW had lost money for most of the decade.
At the annual general meeting on 9 December 1959, the board proposed a takeover by Daimler-Benz (Mercedes). The shareholders were about to approve it. Then Herbert Quandt, a BMW dealer and industrialist who held a small stake, stood up and argued against the deal. He proposed a capital increase instead: he would invest his own money to keep BMW independent.
The shareholders voted down the Mercedes takeover. Quandt increased his stake to 60% and became BMW's controlling shareholder. He funded the development of the BMW 700 and then the 'New Class' (the 1500, launched in 1962), which defined BMW as a maker of sporty sedans. The company that was hours from becoming a Mercedes subsidiary became the most profitable car company in the world. The story is told in interviews and books as the shareholder meeting that changed the German auto industry.
Why it happened
- BMW's post-war strategy was a barbell: luxury cars at the top, microcars at the bottom, and nothing in the middle. The middle — the sporty sedan — was the market that was growing
- The Mercedes takeover was rational from the board's perspective: BMW was losing money, Mercedes had the capital. But the takeover would have eliminated BMW as an independent brand
- Quandt's intervention was not charity — it was a bet that BMW's engineering talent, properly directed, could build a car the market wanted. The bet was on the people, not the product
The lesson
A company about to be acquired for its assets may be worth more as a going concern — if someone bets on the people rather than the balance sheet. Quandt bet on BMW's engineers.
Aftermath
The Quandt family remains BMW's largest shareholder. BMW became the most profitable car company in the world by the 1990s. The 'New Class' strategy — sporty sedans in the middle of the market — defined BMW's brand for the next 60 years. The 1959 shareholder meeting is cited in German business history as the moment BMW was saved.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Porsche built an SUV — the purists said it was the end of the brand. It saved the company.
The Albrecht brothers split a 300-store empire over whether to sell cigarettes
Volkswagen lost about €2bn on the Phaeton, its chairman's personal project
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.