The encyclopedia · R&D & Science · Strategic decision · 2016
BIA 10-2474: 6 volunteers in a French trial, 1 dead, 5 with brain damage
Bial's experimental drug killed one volunteer and left five with brain damage in a French Phase I trial — the molecule was abandoned, the CRO was blamed.
Bial-Portela & Ca. · Biotrial · 2016-01
What happened
BIA 10-2474 was an experimental FAAH inhibitor developed by Bial, a Portuguese pharmaceutical company, for conditions including anxiety, Parkinson's disease, chronic pain, and obesity. The Phase I trial was conducted by Biotrial, a French CRO, in Rennes, France. The drug had been tested in 90 volunteers across earlier dose groups without serious issues. In January 2016, the multiple ascending dose phase began with a 50 mg/day group — a dose that was 80 times higher than needed for complete FAAH inhibition.
On 10 January 2016, the first volunteer in the 50 mg group became ill with stroke-like symptoms. The other five subjects received their sixth dose on 11 January before the trial was suspended. All six were hospitalized. Guillaume Molinet, 49, was declared brain dead on 17 January and died. The other four surviving volunteers suffered deep hemorrhagic and necrotic brain lesions, with doctors describing their injuries as 'irreversible handicap.' Two survivors still had memory impairment and cerebellar syndrome nine months later.
The exact toxicity mechanism was never fully determined, but the French regulator's report identified poor target selectivity, excessive dosing, and non-linear drug accumulation at higher doses. Biotrial was criticised for not stopping the trial when the first subject was hospitalised and for not immediately reporting the incident. Bial permanently abandoned the molecule in July 2016. The European Investment Bank had provided €110 million for Bial's FAAH programme. France and the EU revised first-in-human trial guidelines in response.
Why it happened
- The drug showed poor selectivity for its target enzyme and accumulated at higher doses because elimination pathways became saturated — a combination that was never detected in earlier dose groups.
- The dose jump from 20 mg to 50 mg was too large — the final dose was 80 times higher than needed for complete FAAH inhibition, and the protocol did not allow dose adjustments based on emerging data.
- Biotrial failed to stop the trial when the first volunteer was hospitalised, did not report the incident, and gave the remaining subjects another dose — the CRO turned a crisis into a catastrophe.
The lesson
A dose 80 times higher than needed is not a safety margin — it is a gamble, and the CRO that keeps dosing after the first volunteer is hospitalised is not a partner, it is a liability.
Sources
- Wikipedia — BIA 10-2474
- France brain-damaged drug trial to be probed by prosecutors — BBC News (Jan 2016)
- Man dies after French drug trial hospitalisation — BBC News (Jan 2016)
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Hydroxychloroquine champion Didier Raoult — 46 retractions, 218 concerns
Peter Gøtzsche expelled from Cochrane — the evidence watchdog banished its own co-founder
Bial trial killed one and brain-damaged four at 40x the therapeutic dose
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.