Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2008–2013

Best Buy entered the UK with 11 stores — it lost $2.3B and left in 3 years

Best Buy's 2008 joint venture was meant to bring electronics retail to Britain. It opened 11 stores, closed them all by 2012, and took a $2.3B charge.

Best Buy · 2013-04

What happened

In May 2008, Best Buy agreed to a 50/50 joint venture with The Carphone Warehouse valued at $2.1 billion. The plan was to bring Best Buy's big-box electronics retail model to the UK, combining it with Carphone Warehouse's mobile phone expertise. The first Best Buy store opened in Thurrock in April 2010, and 10 more followed.

The concept failed to resonate with British consumers. The stores were large, expensive to operate, and faced fierce competition from established UK retailers like Dixons (Currys/PC World), online players like Amazon, and the supermarkets that sold electronics at thin margins. The UK market was already saturated, and Best Buy's US-style big-box format did not offer enough differentiation.

In November 2011, Best Buy bought Carphone Warehouse's share of their US mobile phone joint venture for $1.3 billion, but the UK stores continued to bleed money. By early 2012, all 11 UK stores were closed. In April 2012, Best Buy took a $2.3 billion charge related to its UK operations — effectively admitting the entire European experiment was a write-off.

In April 2013, Best Buy sold its 50% stake in the European joint venture back to Carphone Warehouse for approximately $775 million. The total loss on the UK venture was over $1.5 billion. Best Buy never returned to Europe. The failure is a textbook case of a successful US retailer assuming its model would work in a different market without adapting to local competition and consumer behaviour.

Why it happened

  • Best Buy assumed its US big-box model would work in the UK without adapting to a market already served by Dixons, Amazon, and supermarkets selling electronics at low margins.
  • The 11-store footprint was too small to achieve the economies of scale that made Best Buy's US operations profitable — each store carried high fixed costs with no volume to spread them across.
  • The 2008 financial crisis and subsequent recession made UK consumers price-sensitive at exactly the wrong time for a premium-format electronics retailer to launch.
  • Best Buy's joint venture structure with Carphone Warehouse created strategic confusion — the two partners had different priorities and the UK stores never had clear operational ownership.
What it cost$2.3B write-off; 11 stores closed; full European exitcostly

The lesson

A retail model that works in one market does not transfer automatically. Best Buy's big-box format succeeded in the US because of scale — 11 stores in the UK could never replicate that advantage.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →