The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 2021
Sonic's co-creator shipped a platformer with no jump button, and it flopped
Balan Wonderworld replaced core controls with 80+ single-use costumes, reviewers called it unplayable, and Naka left Square Enix weeks after launch.
Square Enix · 2021-03-26
What happened
Square Enix funded Balan Wonderworld as the debut title from Balan Company, a new internal studio led by Sonic the Hedgehog co-creator Yuji Naka and character designer Naoto Ohshima, betting their pedigree would carry a new 3D platformer.
The finished game shipped without a dedicated jump button, replacing standard platforming mechanics with more than 80 costumes that each granted a single disposable ability, and cut a planned tutorial and difficulty options late in development over creative disagreements inside the studio.
Reviews were overwhelmingly negative on release. Japanese sales data showed only about 2,100 physical copies sold in its opening week, and the game was widely reported discounted within weeks. Naka announced his departure from Square Enix roughly two months after launch, citing the company undervaluing the team's work.
Why it happened
- Square Enix greenlit the project on the strength of Naka and Ohshima's reputations without validating the core gameplay loop.
- Cutting the tutorial and difficulty settings late in development removed the only onboarding for a control scheme that departed from genre norms.
- Nobody caught that removing a standard jump button broke the basic expectation players bring to a 3D platformer.
- The studio's internal creative conflict reached the public only after the game had already shipped and failed.
The lesson
A famous name behind a game is not a substitute for playtesting whether the core mechanic actually works.
Aftermath
Naka left Square Enix days after criticizing the company publicly, and later joined a rival studio. Balan Wonderworld became a shorthand example in the games industry for a pedigree-driven project shipped without adequate testing.
Sources
- Game Rant — Balan Wonderworld Seems To Be A Massive Sales Flop
- PlayStation LifeStyle — Sonic Co-Creator Yuji Naka Leaves Square Enix Following Balan Wonderworld Flop
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Foamstars: Square Enix's live-service shooter went free-to-play in eight months
Babylon's Fall: PlatinumGames' live-service gamble shut down in 11 months
Babylon's Fall shipped as an always-online game and fell to 1 PC player within months
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.