The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2017
Ant Fortune's poverty-shaming fund posters backfired — apology and takedown in a day
In September 2017 Ant Fortune and 16 fund firms posted slogans like 'the older you get, the less people forgive your poverty'. Backlash forced an apology.
Ant Fortune (蚂蚁财富) · 2017-09
What happened
On 28 September 2017, Ant Fortune (蚂蚁财富), the wealth-management arm of Ant Financial, launched a campaign of '扎心' (heart-stabbing) posters jointly with 16 fund companies, circulated through the Alipay channel. The copy included "年纪越大，越没有人会原谅你的穷" (the older you get, the less people forgive your poverty), "你每天都很困，只因为你被生活所困" (you are tired every day because life has you trapped), and "每天都在用六位数的密码，保存着两位数的存款" (every day you use a six-digit password to protect a two-digit balance).
The posters drew immediate criticism as 'anxiety marketing' (贩卖焦虑) and, in a Xinjing Bao commentary, a 'toxic chicken soup' full of malice. That evening Alipay issued a statement denying any involvement, saying the ads used Alipay's name without authorization and demanding they be removed.
Around 8pm Ant Fortune apologized on its official Weibo: it acknowledged that "there are many kinds of copy, and we happened to pick the least suitable one". It stressed that Ant Fortune and Alipay are separate legal entities, that the campaign was made and run without any communication with Alipay, apologized to users, to Alipay and to the 16 fund companies, and said the ads had been deleted.
No regulator fine followed. The episode became the textbook Chinese case of financial 'anxiety marketing' backfiring: a campaign meant to nudge young people toward investing instead made its audience feel insulted, and the brand's attempt to distance itself from its own parent ecosystem read as blame-shifting.
Why it happened
- The creative hook was built on the audience's poverty — the ads told young savers their balances were pathetic. A joke on your own target customer converts the audience into the offended party.
- The ads ran through the Alipay channel without Alipay's sign-off, so when backlash hit, the platform distanced itself publicly instead of defending the campaign, leaving the brand apologizing alone.
- With 16 fund companies co-signing the campaign, the apology had to face every partner while the creative had passed through no one who could say 'stop'.
The lesson
Anxiety marketing bills you within hours. If the joke in your ad is on your own customer's wallet, the apology and takedown only stop the bleeding — the 'brand that understands me' is gone.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
JD Finance's loan ad mocked a migrant worker — two apologies and punishments in a week
A ¥6.3B rescue couldn't stop a ¥23.7B writedown at China's mall giant
Gome's founder surrendered the company to a creditor for HK$377M
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.