Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Trading & Investing · Financial decision · 2024

All Blue's wrong-way short bets failed to settle — and cost Nomura and Mizuho >$100M

All Blue's wrong-way short bets couldn't settle; the fallout left Japan's two biggest banks facing over $100M.

All Blue Capital · Nomura Holdings · Mizuho Financial Group · 2024-05

What happened

All Blue Capital, an investment fund led by managing partner Matt Novak, a former emerging-markets trader at Commerzbank, made a series of wrong-way short bets with multiple counterparties in early 2024. According to New York legal filings, the fund was allegedly unable to settle the trades, and two of its units were placed into liquidation in the British Virgin Islands in March 2024.

The failure to settle triggered a chain of losses across some of Japan's largest financial institutions. Nomura Holdings was left nursing a possible loss of 14 billion yen, while Mizuho claimed in a New York lawsuit that All Blue owed it $19 million that it had not repaid. Combined, the potential losses exceed $100 million.

The affair raised fresh questions about risk management at Nomura and Mizuho, both still repairing their controls after the roughly $3 billion collapse of Archegos Capital Management in 2021. Nomura set aside funds to cover the potential loss in April, which pushed its European subsidiary into a pretax loss for the quarter. All Blue contested the claims and called Mizuho a "disgruntled purported unsecured creditor."

Why it happened

  • A single fund making wrong-way short bets with many counterparties concentrated the risk at the banks on the other side of the trades, so one settlement failure hit Nomura and Mizuho at once.
  • Failing to settle when the bets went against it meant the fund's counterparties were left holding losses they had not expected, turning a trading error into a credit event.
  • Japan's biggest banks had not fully closed the counterparty-risk gaps Archegos exposed in 2021, so a smaller version of the same failure could still produce nine-figure losses.
What it cost>$100M for Nomura and Mizuho; two All Blue units liquidatedcostly

The lesson

A counterparty's inability to settle is a risk you can price only if you know how leveraged it is — All Blue's failed shorts became a nine-figure credit loss for the banks on the other side.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →