Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 1859–2015

A&P was the world's largest retailer in 1930 — by 2015 every store was closed

A&P went from 15,000 stores and 10% of US grocery spending to Chapter 11 twice, ending with a liquidation that closed every store by Thanksgiving 2015.

Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company · 2015-07-19

What happened

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company, known as A&P, was founded in New York City in 1859 and grew to become the world's largest retailer by 1930, with more than 15,000 stores and $2.9 billion in sales. In the 1940s, A&P captured 10% of all US grocery spending — twice as large as Sears and four times the size of Kroger. The company was a retail pioneer, introducing the economy store format and the cash-and-carry model that eliminated credit and delivery.

The decline began in the 1950s. A&P paid out most of its profits as dividends to satisfy trust income needs, starving the business of capital for modernization. It invested heavily in private-label manufacturing while national brands, boosted by the rise of television advertising, grew in demand. A&P's workforce was older and more expensive than competitors', and the company tried to offset this by understaffing stores — leading to long lines and empty shelves. By the time Walmart and discount grocers emerged, A&P had lost decades of competitive ground.

On December 12, 2010, A&P filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy with $2.5 billion in assets and $3.2 billion in debt, operating 395 stores. It emerged as a private company in early 2012, but the turnaround never materialized. On July 19, 2015, A&P filed for Chapter 11 again, now with 296 stores and 28,500 employees. The next day, it announced the sale of its stores to Albertsons, Stop & Shop, and regional grocers. All supermarkets were closed by Thanksgiving 2015.

Why it happened

  • A&P paid out profits as dividends rather than reinvesting in stores, leaving the chain stuck with outdated formats and understocked shelves.
  • The company bet on private-label manufacturing while national brands captured consumer loyalty through TV advertising — A&P's smaller stores could not keep both in stock.
  • A&P's older, unionized workforce cost more than competitors' newer employees, and the company's response was to understaff rather than restructure.
  • A&P was slow to adapt to the supermarket format in the 1950s, the discount format in the 1970s, and Walmart's rise in the 1990s — each delay compounded the next.
What it cost$3.2B debt; 28,500 jobs lost; 296 stores liquidatedcatastrophic

The lesson

The world's largest retailer can become extinct in one lifetime. When a company pays out its future in dividends, there is no investment left to compete with the next generation of stores.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →